I have only ordered their mixed berry crisp, which was delicious. Also, you don't need a reservation.
The desserts all look wonderful! We shared cheesecake and it was very good. No reservations needed. It's a pretty casual place.
Available desserts always vary, but are amazing. I've had their cheesecake and peanut butter pie. Walk in is usually fine, but can be worth making a reservation just to be safe during their busy times (Friday/Saturday evenings).
Chocolate Lava Cake is my favorite. Peanut butter pie 2nd fave. They have a Canoli cake that others really like but I prefer a real canoli. Reservations arent needed but I would highly recommend especially on weekends... they can be very busy!
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.