Yes, lids should be removed
I'm confused about her statement of donating her bottles
We request that lids be removed from plastic bottles, separated lids could be brought as part of the total load. CalRecycle don’t want us to pay for debris & water. We don’t get reimbursed for fluid, debris etc. matter of fact we get cited for not inspecting the material before accepting it.
I go there at least twice a week & I've never taken my lids off. Just make sure there's no liquids left in them is all.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.