Do you have turtles?

I don't think they usually have turtles, but calling is the best way to check. If they don't, consider calling Tropical Hut, a reptile +aquatic specialty pet store off of Division and 39th. Turtles are very tricky animals to care for well, and usually get much larger than people anticipate. This leads to a high rate of turn-over, neglect, or 'releasing' into the local pond. This in turn makes many small pet stores hesitant to carry them.

I believe they do, but you should call them to make sure.