Costello's Market

Roxanne

I’m sad that we just discovered this place after 15 years. The food is delicious and the staff is amazing!

Primary Instinct

Food is always fantastic! My only complaint is that it is so popular sometimes the lines are long if you show up without ordering in advance. Pro tip! Order ahead of time so that you don’t have to wait!

Maruta Kajaks-Grots

Yummy "proper" subs. Lot's of meat and cheese. Husband had the calamari dinner. Crispy, light, not greasy or doughy. Took some deli to go, olives, vinegary marinated mushrooms and marinated gigante beans that were creamy with a pleasant tang. If ever in the area again, I will make it a point to stop by. Loved it.

john seighman

This place is amazing for being a small shop. The clerk is absolutely wonderful who makes everyone feel welcome. And the sandwiches there are second to none….the quality and taste is amazing…a must go to place for Middlebury residents and visitors alike