Otter Creek Bakery & Deli

oules 278

Don't waste your money! Ordered a cheesecake for mother's day and to say we were disappointed would be an understatement. It was grossly overcooked and had an unpleasant texture. Strawberry orange flavors came across as acidic/chemical/ almost soapsy. Will not be going back.

Melanie Wilkinson

I normally don't bother with reviews but this place deserves only the best from their customers. This is hands-down the cutest, most delicious bakery I have ever been to in my entire life. The coffee was amazing, the pastries were flaky and tender and perfectly sweet (we shared the apple turnover, maple Danish, & Otter claw), and the people were ridiculously friendly. If you are ever in Middlebury (which is also adorable), please please please do yourself a favor and stop in here.

Nikolina Dobreva

Service was fast and my sandwich delicious. Their coffee was mediocre though. I got a cappuccino and the milk tasted burned. If you stick to pastries and sandwiches though, you'll be fine. Everything is fresh and done to order. Extra props for cleanliness and the covid restrictions in place. They somehow managed to make the bakery feel both safe and normal!

Jenni Klauder

Otter Creek made the cake and cupcakes for our wedding and they were DELICIOUS!! Everything was absolutely incredible, we received so many compliments. They even handled the delivery and setup which was a huge huge help. We can't wait to go back and eat more cupcakes—highly recommend!!