Molly Pitcher Brewing Company

Category: Brewpub in Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Address: 139 W High St, Carlisle, PA 17013, USA

Phone: +17174225591

Opening hours

Sunday: 11AM–9PM

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: Closed

Wednesday: 11AM–9PM

Thursday: 11AM–11PM

Friday: 11AM–11PM

Saturday: 11AM–11PM

Reviews

Bill Grimes

Jun 24, 2022

Very nice place. Have enjoyed their beer for a while and finally visited. Good people and food was fantastic. Thank you. Cheers 🍻 Bill.

Jim Link

Mar 20, 2022

The appetizers we had were great and came quickly even with it being rather busy. Beer was excellent, great selection and was very reasonably priced. Server was very attentive and gave good suggestions on the beer.

_ GRAMCRAKKA _

Mar 17, 2022

Sorry but the experience was very embarrassing. We brought in about 20 or so people with about 10 more lagging behind. Avg age probably around 45. Your "not your waitress" treated everyone like children. Party greater than 6 one check we can understand that. Must be seated to order sounded a little annoying. Couldn't order at the bar either. But to have an attitude right off the bat with everyone as soon as they come in doesn't open peoples wallets. About 10 of the people were never in your establishment before. Probably won't be back. Who knows. So between that and everyone who was going to order food and 3 or 4 drinks im assuming ya lost out a little bit. Probably won't make a difference me writing this review. But if this is how you treat everyone who comes in with a larger party then i cant see us coming back again. We as in myself and 2 others used to stop in once or twice a month. Not sure the newbies will be back either. Everyone was pretty annoyed with the treatment. We probably spent over 2k the previous times we have come in. This group would have been close to that. Everyone drove and nobody was sloppy drunk if you are wondering. Happy st. Patrick's day.

Roxy Darius

Feb 22, 2022

One of our favorite spots! ❀ The staff are all friendly and attentive. Many taps to choose from, if you enjoy locally brewed beverages. 🍺 I enjoyed one that used 50 pounds if carrots grown at Dickinson college. It was really good! Food is reliably good and original. Thank you, MP!!!

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Does the Molly Picture Peanut Porter come in bottles? Great texture. Great taste. Great follow thru. Want to share with friends/relatives out of state/area. Continue we’ll in β€œbuilding” Woody

Woody M | May 24, 2018
Judy Stewart | May 25, 2018

Yes! You can purchase at Molly Pitchers in Carlisle. It is also available in a few distributor locations in Carlisle.

Read More

Does your new location have off street parking?

Sito Montano | May 24, 2019
Steve Hunsecker | May 25, 2019

It does not. Street parking and public lot parking is available close by.

Read More

Did you change the recipe for your cheesy beef soup?

Paul Raver | May 23, 2020
Paul Raver | May 24, 2020

I have had it several times and found it delicious...maybe just a bad onion today, or a garlic spill?

Read More

I visited recently. Does MP sell their beer outside the retail establishment such as beer distributors?

Rob | May 23, 2020
Michael Kolar | May 24, 2020

Yes they do.

Read More

Do they serve root beer? If so, what brand, and is it on tap, bottle, or from the fountain?

Jon Rush | May 24, 2019
Meredith Gatling | May 25, 2019

I don't recall root beer on their menu

Read More

If 1 member of our group doesn't drink beer, what other beverages are available? Can we BYO?

Ann Hoffman | May 24, 2019
Molly Pitcher Brewing Company (Owner) | May 25, 2019

Hi Ann. We offer Pennsylvania wines and cider as well as a few mixed cocktail options.

Read More

Do you need a reservation?

Maureen Mullen | May 24, 2019
James Muldoon | May 25, 2019

No

Read More

When does the new location open?

Heather Anne Blocker | May 24, 2019
sharon kolar | May 25, 2019

Wednesday July 18 @ 11 am. We can hardly wait!!πŸ˜€

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places