City Barbeque and Catering

Lady in Red

The place was hot as heck! No air, and the staff was sweating. That means touching your face and putting on gloves without hand washing! Young staff, but kind! I finally found an establishment that had good ribs, so that was a plus!😊 The brisket was good, but a lil cold . Young man replaced it promptly and was very kind about it! Turkey is good .. better tasting cold after being refrigerated. The fries were delicious and also I love their horseradish sauce! When I asked for it to be cold the young lady looked at me surprised and said... It's supposed to be cold. I told her other places have it sitting out.. she exclaimed.. ' that's why we're the best!'😆😆. And the lemonade and sweet tea ( Arnold Palmer) was delicious! I had to buy a gallon!! Yum 😋. I'll drive there again, as I live about 30 minutes away... Get the air fixed though!😊

Triece Dykes

This was the worst bbq I've ever had. I ordered the bbq brisket sandwich. The pic on the menu shows sliced brisket and I received what I guess was chopped, it looked more like pulled pork. The meat was dry, there was no fat, no bbq sauce and the bun was oddly soft on the inside and hard around the edges. City BBQ had been recommended to me when I was in Indianapolis but unfortunately I didn't get to try it then so when I got the opportunity I thought why not. I don't recommend this particular location and the next time I'm in Indianapolis I'm gonna try the one there to see if there's a difference.

Christina S

Ordered from them months ago had mold on the bread. The sent a credit I gave them the benefit of the doubt and Ordered again. Pork was very fatty, mac and cheese was cold and tasted like refrigerator, banana pudding was gritty, corn pudding had lots of hard kernels. French fries were great but won't be back.

Peter Mills

Prices are getting a little higher than what I thought they would be. A combo plate with a side is more than $20. Service was a bit slower than I would have liked. I remember the beer selection being better in the past. The food was good though! Served hot and tasty. Great brisket! That redeemed the slow service and high price.