Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern

Barbara Collins

Delicious food, I think I got a Philly and it was the best I've ever had. Service was great, atmosphere was very chill. Would definitely go back!

Anne Thomas

Enjoy dinner here once a week at least. Great atmosphere! Advise to make reservation for dinner on weekends.

Nate S

first let me start by saying we used to come here often. Over the last couple years it has went down hill. I was here with my family and friends, I ordered a pizza with extra cheese they brought out a pizza with no cheese, I sent it back it took them about 20 mins to remake the pizza, by that time my party was done eating. Thee manager comes out and says he'll take care of it, Our waitress brings us our bill I give her my card she comes back minutes later and says "Im so sorry, I think we took the pizza off twice" Why not double check the bill before you bring it? Service was Poor , the food was average.... With New Albany not having alot of food options it sucks because we have come here so much but we most likely will not be returning to this location.

Dale Dillhoff

Very nice restaurant. Great location and very good food. Service was very good with a courteous staff.