The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Westerville

Norman Haney

Always a safe bet.

Jazz Stoneman

extremely over salted chicken tender batter. it was inedible. very disappointed.

Henry GaFai Lee

Great venue for having a wedding reception on the third floor. My best bud, Stew and Jennifer tied the knot today. Perfect size for 60 people. Clean, wheel chair accessible, and great food! Famous Fish & chips are their signature dish, especially with their tartar sauce. Everything was delicious, including the French fries, yams, chicken breast, green beans, salad and dinner rolls… but don’t forget to leave room for the CARROT CAKE! The absolute best I’ve ever eaten in my life! delicious!

Brian Guffey

The Old Bag of Nails in Westerville is a must go. The restaurant is located in Westerville where there are tons of shops and old buildings on the street. The restaurant itself is located in an old building, with possibly original floors and ceilings. Our servers are always nice and they were patient with my wife while she sampled some of the seasonal brew options. It is a beautiful old building both on the outside and interior. Very well maintained, good sanitation practices and overall a great establishment. All I have to say is come hungry though because when you get Fish and Chips they give you two big battered delicious filets. I tried the Eddie Style battering for the first time. It has a kick to it but dip it in the beer cheese, ranch and buffalo sauce combination and it is a great fish for dipping. I also recommend the pickle spears they do come in six but only pictured four because well they are so hard to not eat at first. I am not much of a pickle person, but I do like fried pickles though. What I like about the pickle spears is that they are not too vinegary, bitter, salty, slimey or too sweet. The batter makes the pickle just right and I recommend the beer cheese to dip them in. My wife did try their seasonal apple cinnamon beer non IPA brew. It was good and reminded her of an apple cider with a hint of spice from the cinnamon at the end. I hope you can visit it soon and while you are there check out the small businesses on the street. My recommendation is Shirley's if you want to feel nostalgic and get gourmet fresh popped assorted popcorn.