Toby's Tavern

Martha W Johnson

Toby’s is our go-to lunch spot when visiting Whidbey Island! Their Parrot Red Ale is delicious. And Those Mussels!! So meaty and good. The Sunday special Thai Curry mussels are to die for, served with ample garlic bread for soaking up the saucy goodness. Fine, fun, and efficient service with a smile (and a little bit of rubbing). We always feel at home there!

Don Nelson

It was a nice, sunny Friday. While taking my normal walk at lunch, passing Toby's I read their special Muscle stew with Bread. They were very busy, I had to wait about 10 minutes for my to go order. Walked back to work, sat down at my desk and enjoyed my tasty stew with toasted bread and cookie.

Erin McGee

I'm not deeply into seafood but the mussels here are incredible. They had a Thai curry mussel special and the flavors were amazing and exactly what we needed to warm up after a long, cold walk by the water. Great vibe, very cozy and friendly.

Dave Sweeney

We stopped because a friend told how well they prepare their steamed Penn Cove mussels. The reality lived up to the hype. They were great. Especially paired with the Toby Parrot Red Ale. The staff were pleasant and fun. Great place to grab a beer and some good food.