I know it's been a bar since the sixties. I don't know when it adopted that name, but it went by that name when I first went there around 2008.
At least since the early 70's
A colorful history. It was Toby's when we moved to the island in 1975. Not sure if they include it on their website or FB page.
Seems like forever!
I believe it's been Toby's Tavern for at least 60 yrs. A family member grew up on Whidbey Island and remembers it as Toby's for at least that long.
The wooden bar itself is from the late 1800s. Don't know abt the tavern. I would say the 40s or 50s.
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.