Buttermilk Bakeshop

Andrey Mego

I worked with Buttermilk Bakeshop to cater a wedding cake and cookies for my reception. They are responsive and responsible. One less thing to stress about. Oh and the desserts are ridiculous. So delicious. I know there are many bakeries in NY but i only need this one.

Patrick Rekczis

Nice display of goods. Had the apple cookie and a caramel cornflakes bar. Both were good. I would stop back and love to try the cakes they offer.

FRS

A showstopper cake that was as delicious as it was beautiful. While not a traditional baby shower cake it was perfect as flowers represent new beginnings - and that's what babies are! Katie and her team are lovely, accommodating professionals who clearly care about their creations and their clients. Thank you Buttermilk team for making our family's special day that much more amazing.

athina nicolaou

Buttermilk Bakeshop made our wedding cake, and my guests LOVED it! We were a little bit picky in choosing a flavor, since my husband doesn't eat chocolate, so they made us a vanilla espresso cake that was to die for. Highly recommend.