Cresskill Bagel Cafe

SLF 509

Good bagel, that's where it ends. Placed our order with a limited English employee who also spoke as if she was in a library. We ordered 3 bagels and a coffee, she wrote it down. She came back to tell me one of the bagels wasn't available and gave me options on a replacement, which I selected. Then she came back to ask if the coffee was iced or hot and I said hot. Then she wanted to know, since I ordered milk and sugar, how many sugars did we want. Then we cash out for about $13, and left. Open our bag. When we got home to find out only two bagels and a coffee. She wrote it down, how can you screw that up? Felt like we were part of the cattle call in this place and she couldn't understand me and I couldn't understand her. $13 later, we had to go to another bagel place to fill in the missing order. Not worth the trip, off the list.

Jerry Squillante

Always fresh and quick service..Great place best bagels around.

Philip Leger

Great bagel sandwiches

Lilly Brignoni

I’m so mad at myself for agreeing to pay $8.50 for this bagel (see photo). I ordered an everything bagel toasted with cream cheese, tomato, and bacon. He charged me for “Taylor ham and cheese $7.99 add tomato $0.50” and I said, it’s just bacon and tomato added he said “it’s the same price” 🤯 literally the biggest rip off for a bagel place and the bagels aren’t even noteworthy, they’re average at best. Also they’re SO stingy with the cream cheese and other ingredients it’s insane. The bagel I received was worth $3.50 with the amount of bacon, one slice of tomato, and one small dollop of cream cheese he put on it. This place used to be so good, I’m literally never returning because I’d rather spend my money on quality, fair priced food. So disappointing.