Classic Rarities, LLC Top Coin Dealer Buffalo, NY

Category: Coin dealer

Address: BY APPOINTMENT, 71 Main St, Hamburg, NY 14075, USA

Phone: +17168639099

Opening hours

Sunday: Closed

Monday: 11AM–5PM

Tuesday: 11AM–5PM

Wednesday: 11AM–5PM

Thursday: 11AM–5PM

Friday: 11AM–5PM

Saturday: 11AM–2PM

Reviews

Daniel Mazza

Oct 16, 2022

Very professional service, fair and honest. John was easy to work with and educated me through the entire process. I strongly recommend him to everyone.

Chelsea Lewis

Oct 13, 2022

I’m from out of area his hours said he was open drove all the way out here just to meet a rude terrible looking woman and be informed once I left the woman who looked me up and down that he is out of area till Tuesday. A professional business should update their hours so people don’t waste their time and have awful interactions like this one!

James Wood

Oct 5, 2022

Recently did business with Classic Rarities and as someone with limited knowledge obtained solely from the web, he took the time to explain pricing and values based on the info I had been looking at. I had a sense of trust from the minute I walked in the door, not pushy, the estimate and offers he gave me were within the expected ranges I had researched. He always responded to any communications in a very prompt manner. I highky recommend classic rarities to anyone looking for an honest evaluation and fair value estimates and offers.

Joseph Schlossin

Sep 22, 2022

Excellent service very friendly great place to bring your coins A++++++++++

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Looking for coin(s) for a xmas gift for a beginner collector!$25-30 range. Got anything?

Jolene Delgado | Oct 28, 2018
Classic Rarities, LLC Top Coin Dealer Buffalo, NY | Sep 27, 2022

Please call me to discuss your interest in coins. I only buy coins and currently don’t sell retail. Thanks John 716-863-9099

Read More

Hi I have some rare coins. Can you help me where to go please?

Mue Paw | Oct 27, 2020
Jack Bailie (Jack and Jewel) | Oct 27, 2021

John Magavern. 71 Main St. Hamburg.

Is there any value above face value for a tube of 48 state quarters uncirculated?

Kim Jablonski | Oct 28, 2019
Willard Magavern | Oct 27, 2020

Sorry, those wouldn’t be for me. Thanks

Hello, I tried ordering the 2018 US Mint silver proof reverse set but they are currently unavailable or sold out. Do you have this product in stock ? Thanks, Brian

Brian Gable | Oct 28, 2018
Willard Magavern | Oct 27, 2020

Sorry, I am a wholesaler and don’t do any retail sales. Thanks

do you buy old stamps ?

Peter Brown | Oct 28, 2018
Classic Rarities, LLC Top Coin Dealer Buffalo, NY | Oct 28, 2018

Sorry, no I don't. Just U.S. coins and currency.

Are they interested in anything other than coins?

Lisa Pasnik | Oct 28, 2018
Classic Rarities, LLC Top Coin Dealer Buffalo, NY | Oct 27, 2020

Joshua, please give me a call to discuss your coins. Thanks

Read More

I have substantial Canadian coins and am interested in selling them. Does anyone from your store travel around Jamestown N.Y. looking to buy coins. Substantial pennies, nickels, dimes, and silver dollars.

Robert Buerkle | Oct 27, 2022
Classic Rarities, LLC Top Coin Dealer Buffalo, NY | Oct 27, 2022

Please give me a call tomorrow to discuss your coins. Thanks, John Classic Rarities, LLC

I hope someone finally responds. Is there value in a 1977 penny, no mint, that is noticeably thicker at the rim and when stacked is noticeably smaller in diameter than every other penny

Jim Denaro | Jul 29, 2022
Classic Rarities, LLC Top Coin Dealer Buffalo, NY | Jul 29, 2022

This is the first time I have seen this question posted. So as for finally answering you, this is almost immediately after you posted your question. It doesn't sound like anything I would be interested in, but if you want to text me a few close-up photos I will gladly give you my opinion. Thanks, Classic Rarities, LLC

Do you buy United States proof sets? I have 1981, 19831983, 1986, and 2 - 1776-1976 sets.

Annette Accordino | May 30, 2022
Classic Rarities, LLC Top Coin Dealer Buffalo, NY | May 30, 2022

Yes, Please give me a call. 716-863-9099

Do take Canadian silver coins

Tony Jacobik | Oct 27, 2020
Classic Rarities, LLC Top Coin Dealer Buffalo, NY | Oct 27, 2020

Some Canadian, mostly just for silver. The dimes, quarters, half dollars and silver dollars 1966 and earlier. Also some of the same from 67&68, as well as all gold coins. Hope this helps. Please call for an appointment.

Hai sir I'm from India are you buying India coins sir?

chiluka sruthi | Oct 27, 2020
Classic Rarities, LLC Top Coin Dealer Buffalo, NY | Oct 27, 2020

Sorry, I do not. My primary focus is on U.S. coins and currency. Thank you though.

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places