Hoosier Mama Pie Company

Rita Magdaong

My favorite pie on earth ❤️

Megan Ng

A true blast from the past vibe! The interior feels like being transported into a diner from the 50s. The seating area and shop in general is not too big, and there are two big booths that have nice big windows to people watch! The booths do get a little hot and stuffy though when the sun is bright. I adore how you could get pies by the slice here, and they have so many flavors available! I got the espresso cream and lemon chess pies, and they were delicious. The lemon chess was a classic and the espresso cream had a great balance of flavor, depth, and texture! You could also see the pie making process in the back as well! The staff were helpful and welcoming as well. Cant wait to visit again! :)

Sarah Summerhill

The vibes are immaculate, the coffee is pretty good. Highly recommend a quick trip or a light brunch here.

John Pozo

Lovely pie shop. Feels very welcoming and cozy. The staff was quick and friendly. Ordered a slice of the fruity pebble and pecan pie. Very tasty, flakey/buttery curst. The fillings were pretty balanced didnt taste overly sweet. Also ordered a small banana cream pie, it was a hit at the party. Definitely would be back for some pie.