Mill Pond House

Category: Seafood restaurant

Address: 437 E Main St, Centerport, NY 11721, USA

Phone: +16312617663

Opening hours

Sunday: 12–9PM

Monday: 12–9:30PM

Tuesday: 12–9:30PM

Wednesday: 12–9:30PM

Thursday: 12–9:30PM

Friday: 12–10:30PM

Saturday: 12–10:30PM

Reviews

Geova Love Prints

Jul 19, 2022

Great view! Valet parking available only. Staff very friendly and accommodating. Big seafood variety. Prices very affordable

Rae Allyn

Jul 18, 2022

Was highly recommended but I was embarrassed by bringing my guests here. We traveled far. Dont get their $150 steak for two. Service was great but meal was simply not amazing. I think the lobster mac n cheese included very fake, inedible lobster. Like...use real 🦞 lobster or just offer mac n cheese. I saw the other specials arrive at other tables. No need to return here. I saw a swan in the pond behind me and that was amazing.

Keith Biondo

Jul 9, 2022

Greeted by the parking staff "with do you have a reservation?" Not welcome, but a challenge. Not cool. Inside front was aloof. I know the service and wait staff and they were all cool. Food was still great. Drinks? Gone are cocktail glasses and now served in champagne glasses. I get it. Thanks to man-caused inflation everything costs more. Raise prices then. Don't skimp that way. Bad management changes mean I will try other venues. $320 tab, 2 people.

Sue L

Jun 11, 2022

Delicious shrimp scampi, mashed potatoes and vegetables with a beautiful view on the outdoor covered patio. Service was excellent. Very busy on a beautiful summer Friday evening. Only thing I didn't like was they asked us to vacate the table shortly after we finished eating. If they had a 90 minute table seating policy they should have it posted upon entry.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Hello I loved the artichoke salad please what dressing is used? Thank you

Tara Granfortuna | Apr 23, 2021
piccolo of huntington | Apr 24, 2021

Thanks very much for your feedback. We are glad you enjoyed the salad! The dressing used is a lemon thyme vinaigrette.

Read More

Celebrating husband's 89th birthday. Can we bring a birthday cake?

Joan Pace | Apr 25, 2020
Dean Philippis | Apr 26, 2020

absolutely,, there is a $4 per person plate charge though. thanks for your inquiry.

How do I purchase a gift card??

barbara Chandler | Apr 26, 2019
Mr D | Apr 27, 2019

Call them or stop in and pick one up

Can I beta prix dinner for 18 on a Tuesday. Evening 5:30

florence lucker | Apr 26, 2019
Mill Pond House (Owner) | Apr 27, 2019

Hi Florence, To book a reservation please call the restaurant and ask for Ariana or Ben, 631-261-7663

Going tomorrow night 10-12-18 with another couple- special occasion. 5 year anniversary. First time for us all. Can you advise dress code? Suggestions on what to order? Best spot to sit if able to get a great view. We all are big sunset lovers.

Fran Nichols | Apr 26, 2019
Nancy Brennan | Apr 27, 2019

Dress is Casual . We have worn jeans with nice tops or shirts. I have never had anything there that I didnt like. In daylight the best place to sit but the most popular, is the room with the water view of the pond. There is a large room before that one but I always sit with the pond view . Its very crowded so get there ahead of time. There is no other parking other than valet.

Read More

Do you offer lunch specials (menus & pricing)? If so what hours? Thank you MJ Selvaggio

Mary Jane Selvaggio | Apr 26, 2019
Tamara Foster | Apr 27, 2019

Their food is delicious! Great bar food also

Read More

Do they have a piano? I played there in the 1980s. Is Paul still the owner?

John Clancy | Apr 26, 2019
Big Fig 94 | Apr 27, 2019

Hate to be redundant but no on the piano question and I don't know who the owner is.

Read More

Does it have a fireplace?

Bruce Kitchens | Apr 26, 2018
Allan Csuka | Apr 27, 2018

I did not see one in the area I was seated.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places