Brothers Grim Games and Collectibles

Category: Collectibles store

Address: 1244 Middle Country Rd, Selden, NY 11784, USA

Phone: +16316982805

Opening hours

Sunday: 12–7PM

Monday: 12–11PM

Tuesday: 12–11PM

Wednesday: 12–11PM

Thursday: 12–11PM

Friday: 12–11PM

Saturday: 12–8PM

Reviews

Rose Cox (Angel Icaria)

Oct 19, 2022

A comfortable, welcoming community bolstered by a professionally kept and clean store, perfect for anyone looking for a space to engage in their nerdy hobbies of choice. With weekly events for card-games and war games, including some lesser-known ones, you'll always have something to do here.

John Craig

Oct 17, 2022

The customer service was amazing very knowledgeable staff

John Tropiano Jr.

Oct 14, 2022

This place is a gem that's tucked away. I've been living in the area for about 2 months and am very glad to say I love this place. It's very clean and well stocked. The remodel they did just made things even better. Support your local game store.

mike little

Oct 13, 2022

One of my favorite places to go

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do they carry mini painting supplies, eg paints and media, brushes, and basing supplies?

Vinnie Cavaliere | Oct 21, 2021
Matthew Ambrose | Oct 21, 2021

Yes! They have a pretty decent selection too!

Read More

Do they sell D&D 4e or 5e Books

po panda | Oct 22, 2019
William Countiss | Oct 22, 2019

Both are here. They even have the Dragon Mountain campaign that was released sometime in the 90's. They have a huge selection.

Read More

Do you sell single pokemon cards and or booster packs from previous releases to the most current?

PATRICK HANDLIN | Oct 22, 2018
Christian Carrero | Oct 22, 2018

They have a showcase with some of the more valuable pokemon cards and have a dollar binder for others.

Read More

Do u guy's buy Yu-Gi-Oh card's

Roberto Ross | Oct 22, 2017
Judson Salomon (Skeeve) | Oct 22, 2017

They have a guy on consignment who does. Try Thursday or Saturday evening.

Do they sell Xbox one s new

Aaron stern | Mar 25, 2022
PAT MCKENA | Mar 25, 2022

The video game portion of the business is second hand and retro games, so it is unlikely.

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

Anonymous | Oct 21, 2022
Brothers Grim Games and Collectibles | Oct 21, 2021

Player health and safety is our utmost concern! We have taken multiple steps to ensure so: Masks are mandatory Players are seated 4 ft apart We have installed ionizers in our air system - these kill bacteria, viruses, mold, mycotoxins, and even remove odors!

Can you order tickets online for the pokemon pre release scheduled for today 7/20?

Eileen Moreno | Oct 22, 2019
Brothers Grim Games and Collectibles | Oct 22, 2019

There is no online order or any sign up beforehand. we will not run into any issues with runing out of kits today.

Read More

Do they still have a guy who buys yugioh cards?

J C-Mor | Oct 22, 2019
Aa Aa | Oct 22, 2019

If you call the store they'll be able to tell you the best time to come in and trade.

Read More

Do you earn any prizes in yugioh or pokemon events?

Gavin Wilson | Oct 22, 2018
Lisa Petrow | Oct 22, 2018

Depending on how well you do. Its Credit based.

Do you buy baseball card's

Elizabeth Rhodes | Oct 22, 2018
Nick Ramos | Oct 22, 2018

No, yugioh and magic are prodominantly bought. brendan's sports cards in medford does though. he doesnt buy anything from the 80's

Do you purchase autographed baseballs?

John C Rost | Oct 22, 2018
Brian Spiegel | Oct 22, 2018

I've never seen any sports memorabilia there.

Read More

Can you trade Yu-Gi-Oh cards with the shop for others of the same value?

Patrick Brideson | Oct 22, 2018
Morrighan Moran | Oct 22, 2018

Generally they do not do even trades. If you are looking to do a trade for two cards of equal value, your best bet is to trade with other players in the shop.

Read More

Do you guys hold something similar to a Dungeons and Dragons begginer’s game?

Thomas Phifer | Oct 22, 2018
Alexander Gambino | Oct 22, 2019

for dnd it's more gather some friends and post on the bulletin board by the door "looking for a dm" I know of at least one ongoing game but I have seen other playing Edit: every other Sunday theres a beginner's dnd game. This upcoming Sunday 4/21 we are gathering

Will the appraise and buy Gen 1 Pokemon cards?

DragonsBane Gaming | Oct 22, 2018
Mike Booch | Oct 22, 2018

Good question. They sell singles of various card games so there's a good chance. Best way to know is to call them or stop by. If it's not a busy day they'll take the time to speak with you.

Read More

Will u buy 2000+ Pokémon cards for $1000+

andrew z | Oct 22, 2017
Christian Carrero | Oct 22, 2018

Most likely not since old cards go out of rotation or get reprinted. There are people that will buy bulk amounts of cards, although it won't get you a lot of money per card.

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places