Address: 775 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10025, USA
Phone: +12122802253
Sunday: 10AM–7PM
Monday: 10AM–7PM
Tuesday: 10AM–7PM
Wednesday: 10AM–7PM
Thursday: 10AM–7PM
Friday: 10AM–7PM
Saturday: 10AM–7PM
Kyle Andrews
Great cake shop! Definitely recommend people check it out!
L D
I first visited here about 12 years ago, had a red velvet cupcake, and then split a sweet potato cheesecake with my friend. Before trying that cheesecake, I thoroughly hated cheesecake, but this one was so good, I sobbed while eating it and changed my mind about cheesecake altogether. I think about that cheesecake every day of my life. It's my go-to now, and I can't wait for my next visit, so I can have some more!
Robin Richie
The banana pudding is sumptuous... "Make My Cake NYC" is a NYC treasure! Two thumbs up!
Sam Zollo
Owner seems like an awesome person so I am happy to support this business. Vanilla Cupcake was pretty good, just the frosting was a bit on the sweeter side. Person behind the counter was ok, she was nice but I just wish that she was more upbeat and less monotone.
Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.
The store opened April 1st The grand opening will be in may.
They make any cake you like. The even add photos. Most importantly the cake is absolutely delicious
I don't know if they do, but I kind of doubt it. Call them and inquire!
Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.
Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.