Make My Cake

Category: Bakery in New York

Address: 2380 Adam Clayton Powell Jr Blvd, New York, NY 10030, USA

Phone: +12122342344

Opening hours

Sunday: 9AM–4PM

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 9AM–6PM

Wednesday: 9AM–6PM

Thursday: 9AM–6PM

Friday: 9AM–7PM

Saturday: 9AM–7PM

Reviews

Lenice Footman

Oct 3, 2022

I've always loved the red velvet cake. I travel from the Bronx whenever I want a good piece of cake. This is the place ❤️

Kim Bush

Aug 14, 2022

This bakery used to have really great peach 🍑 cobbler, great crust, peach filling was on point, etc. But not anymore😒. I stopped by here the other day, in search of some great, home made peach cobbler and got the total opposite. The peach filling tasted like it had been sitting for a while and it was cold. I like my cobbler warm. Did not taste homemade. I'm not sure what happened but they need to go back to what they were doing before.

eL-egant Soulfood

Aug 8, 2022

The coconut pineapple cake was delicious. The key lime pie left a lot to be desired. I did like that it wasn't too sweet.

Perpetual Produktions

Jul 9, 2022

Excellent service and a fantastic bakery with so many assortments of baked goodies! So Delicious ! I will be returning very soon for more :)

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Did make my cake in 116 close its doors

America Evins | Oct 22, 2018
Tchiyuka Cornelius | Oct 22, 2018

Yes, they're moving to midtown. 57th street I believe. The 139th street store is the original location. It's always been there and is still open.

Read More

What happened to Make My Cake on 116th Street in Harlem?

Sheran Shaw | Oct 22, 2018
Makeup by Tajlia | Oct 22, 2018

They're setting up a new location at roughly 99th and Columbus. I couldn't believe it. They moved on up to the upper west side like the Jefferson's. What about the community that made them what they are? It's a shame.

Read More

Do they make sugar free cakes or cupcakes?

Donna Adams | Oct 22, 2019
keenan f | Oct 22, 2019

Yes they do

Read More

CAN I PURCHASE A CAKE AT THE 139TH STORE, SAME DAY?

Jeff Reeves | Apr 24, 2022
Kake Culture | Apr 24, 2022

Yes, you can but we recommend placing an order in advance, such as 2 days prior, to guarantee a cake of your choice. Same day options are 7" 8" round cakes, red velvet with cream cheese frosting and filling and butter (vanilla) cake with buttercream frosting and filling.

Read More

Why do they advertise that their establishment opens up at 8:00 am and they are NEVER open at that time? I have been buying my cakes from here over the past ten years , its time to find another bakery. Don't waste my time.

Ton SonNhat | Oct 22, 2018
Tchiyuka Cornelius | Oct 22, 2018

Well, if you already know they don't really open at 8 am, why are you still showing up at that time? Nobody is wasting your time except you. I don't understand the question!

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

Anonymous | Oct 21, 2022
Lynne Mayers-Thomas | Oct 21, 2021

The place is small. They only allow 2 people in at one time. There is a plastic barrier over the counter and a table and plastic barrier between the cashier and player.

Do they make sugar free cakes??

Lakisha Pedraza | Oct 21, 2020
Karim Cabrera | Oct 21, 2020

I think you can request a whole sugar free cake.

Read More

What time does Make my Cake close on July 4th?

Tiana Williams | Oct 22, 2019
LOVELIFE * | Oct 22, 2019

"Happy 4TH of July Tiana"! 🇺🇸🌭🍔🍺🍹🍷🍰🙂 The website states "7:00p.m. - however - being the holiday may differ". 🙁 Hurry!😋

Do they take EBT payment for birthday cakes

Wanda Ortiz | Oct 22, 2018
Bx.DaBoro | Oct 22, 2018

No

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places