The Oyster Company

Graham Bolton

We arrived without reservations (not recommended), and were accommodated almost immediately. Food was good. Service was good. Restaurant was packed. The staff seemed to keep up with the demand. Unfortunately, half of the oysters on the $60 tower appetizer were filled with sand. A lot of sand! Maybe that's to be expected, due to being a fresh catch, but it certainly caught me off guard. Lazy man's Lobster was lack luster and dry. The top had a very thick layer of dry breadcrumbs and the flavor was bland. Lobster Risotto was amazing. Salads were awesome. Paella was delicious. Portions were nice, there was no room for dessert.

Lisa Mayberry

Delicious cocktails and dinner. They had oyster specials until 6:30 for 1.50 each. The paella was good but it seemed more liquid than I'm accustomed to for that dish. Big portions and good service year round is what will keep people coming back.

Tracy Sperling

I had some time while I was on the Cape and a friend recommended this place. It did not disappoint. The signature oysters were really tasty. I was dining alone and was able to walk in and get a nice table. The staff were very friendly and the service and seafood were very fresh.

Adrian Forbes

Great cocktails, and the entrees were spot on for preparedness and flavor. Highly recommend the seared Chatham scallops and paella song with the blackberry old fashioned and rum runner. The kids loved drawing and playing games on the tablecloth.