Sammy's Fish Box

Category: Seafood restaurant in The Bronx, New York

Address: 41 City Island Ave, The Bronx, NY 10464, USA

Phone: +17188850920

Opening hours

Sunday: 11AM–12AM

Monday: 11AM–12AM

Tuesday: 11AM–12AM

Wednesday: 11AM–12AM

Thursday: 11AM–12AM

Friday: 11AM–12AM

Saturday: 11AM–12AM

Reviews

Maria Fernandez

Oct 14, 2022

A perfect place to share and a good atmosphere and good service I am delighted

Charissa Jones

Oct 11, 2022

Family had been coming here for years and always a wonderful experience. I usually stick with the broiled seafood combination, and everything is of big proportion with leftovers for home. You also get cornbread bread and veggies as a house appetizer.

Robin Samuelscgc Hc kic

Oct 11, 2022

A lot of food and not cheap. Same meals

Elsie Wilkins

Oct 11, 2022

The food was awesome. We had a great time with friends

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do they take debit cards?

Shannon Lawrence | Oct 14, 2018
Janita Dunn | Oct 14, 2018

Only if it has a chip if not you have to use their atm

Read More

Do you have to show proof of vaccination?

Jerry Stokes | Oct 13, 2021
ANTWAN ADAMS | Oct 13, 2021

Yes for indoor dinner but hey I respect it fully.

Read More

Can you use a debit or credit card

Danielle Anthony | Oct 14, 2019
Edward Pirraglia | Oct 14, 2019

Yes both and that thing you call Cash

Read More

Do they have a parking lot

Brianna Hidalgo | Oct 14, 2018
Pimp Daddy | Oct 14, 2018

Yes they have valet parking.

Read More

do they have outdoor eating tables?

israel toledo | Oct 13, 2020
Moises Roman | Oct 13, 2020

They have a nice size parking lot turned into distant seating with umbrella covers very nice in my opinion

Read More

Why is it that Sammy's Fish box has become so rude and short with their customers?

Denise Duhart | Oct 14, 2018
Denise Duhart | Oct 14, 2018

I am Pastor and I came with a party of 8 and had a reservation and the greeter was so rude and dis did respectful. Told us until all our party was standing there the would not seat us. She told us to just sit at the BAR until she was ready to seat us. Them several children came and sat at the bar which is illegal and they were jumping around kick me and others sitting there. I asked to see a manager and was told the manager was not in the building. I even called in while I was sitting there. Finally we were seated but not even at the same table together. This was supposed to be a womens gathering and we could not even hear each other because we weren't sitting togather. I've been going since The 70s and the was the first time we were treated poorly. I believe the greater was trying to enpress the manager. She not kind to people of color even though she was a person of color herself

Read More

do they serve hard shell crabs?

Drella Taylor | Oct 14, 2018
Suzie Q | Oct 14, 2018

They have both hard and soft shell seafood.

Read More

Do you have gift card?

Deloris Rose | Oct 14, 2017
Mike Austin | Oct 14, 2017

No

Read More

Is there outside dining at this place?

Jose A. Salamanca | Oct 13, 2020
Cynthia Wofford | Oct 13, 2020

Yes

Read More

Do you have out door dining??

reshia simon | Oct 13, 2020
sandra perez | Oct 13, 2020

Yes they do for now. No one is allow to eat inside the restaurant yet.

Read More

Do Sammy's fish box have indoor or outdoor seating?

Yaw Preko | Oct 13, 2020
F3R_ Salud, Corazón & Felicidad | Oct 13, 2020

For the moment is outdoor,just go and enjoy.

Read More

After putting the $100 deposit down for a 28 person party, do u have to pay extra expenses or do u just pay for food.

Izzy Bizzie | Oct 14, 2019
Christina Salisbury | Oct 14, 2019

You pay for food as well as drinks and then the gratuity (tip)which they give you suggested amounts on the check.

Do you have shrimp alfredo

Carmen Colon | Oct 14, 2019
Latoya Fowler | Oct 14, 2019

Yes

Read More

Do you need reservations

Irewin Softleigh | Oct 14, 2018
Ann-Marie Mangaroo | Oct 14, 2018

No.

Read More

What beverage do you serve?

Sandra Frith | Oct 14, 2018
Big True | Oct 14, 2018

Anything you can think of they have it.

Read More

What kinds of fish do you serve??

Lamar Griffin | Oct 14, 2018
Raul MacBeth | Oct 14, 2018

They have a wide variety of Fresh Fish Not Frozen both foreign and domestic.

Read More

Do u sing happy birthday

Ataliah Gibson | Oct 14, 2017
Doreen Ogan | Oct 14, 2017

Yes they sing happy birthday. You have to tell the hostess once seated. If a party of more than 2 you can tell when you give your name and number for seating. They give a paper crown or tiara for birthday person!

Read More

Should I make a reservation in summer?

A Google User | Oct 14, 2017
Raul MacBeth | Oct 14, 2018

I was with a group and just walked in with no reservations and got sat immediately.

Read More

I WANTED TO KNOW IF SAMMYS IN CITY ISLAND THEY HAVE LOBSTER TAILS ??

Willy Rivera | Mar 17, 2022
K P | Mar 17, 2022

Yes, they do. They can be ordered as a meal exclusively or as add on.

Read More

Does Sammy do catering and how do I obtain a menu?

Annette Franklin | Jan 16, 2022
Craze Almighty | Jan 16, 2022

No they don't for some odd reason

Read More

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

Anonymous | Oct 13, 2022
Robert Gibbs | Oct 13, 2021

Pick up and delivery. I don't think they have dine in

Read More

Do we get served outdoor?

princess daphne | Oct 13, 2020
Anaph_Digital Productions | Oct 13, 2020

They have a outdoors, patio dining section where they serve their 'dining in' patrons.

Read More

Is Sammy available for outside table?

Brian Davis | Oct 13, 2020
Frank Baez | Oct 13, 2020

Yes

Read More

We can go to eat in the restaurant ?

carlos mejia | Oct 13, 2020
Constance Maitland | Oct 13, 2020

Yes. You can eat there.

Read More

Can you sit in

patricia lovera | Oct 13, 2020
joe joe | Oct 13, 2020

Outside dining only

Read More

is Sammy open

Ray Reddon | Oct 13, 2020
Tonya Moore | Oct 13, 2020

Yes..take out only

Read More

Are you allow to bring in a cake for a birthday party

Sandradeen Senior | Oct 14, 2019
isaul cabral | Oct 14, 2019

Yes, we celebrated a birthday and took our own cake.

Is there free parking or you have to pay?

Isael Perez | Oct 14, 2019
Kwame Turner | Oct 14, 2019

Free

Read More

Will you go here again?

david grate | Oct 14, 2019
Corrxpt | Oct 14, 2019

Mabye

Read More

Do you serve vegetarian or vegan dishes as well?

Carmen Mclean | Oct 14, 2019
fitzhugh wallace jr | Oct 14, 2019

Yea, they do.. I not sure about vegan dishes tho

Read More

Do they give you a decent amount of crab legs is it worth the money an the trip to the city ?

diamond walker | Oct 14, 2019
Phillissia | Oct 14, 2019

They are really big, but I personally don't think they worth the money

Read More

Do they have group rates for 25-30 seniors

Gloria Stephney | Oct 14, 2018
Bobby Blankumsee | Oct 14, 2018

Just go it's worth it

Read More

Do they serve drinks or is it B.Y.O.B.?

Anthony Ant La Reed | Oct 14, 2018
Kendra Spencer | Oct 14, 2018

Serve drinks, pina colada is excellent

Read More

The menu is confusing. It is a very busy menu with to many choices. You feel lost! The food and service are good.

Eliot Feldman | Oct 14, 2018
SexxyNic-Lit-Life | Oct 14, 2018

That's a take out spot but they have a better food menu if u dine in

Read More

There used to be good food there until it was sold to new owners now food is not good I love the lobster box instead there food is delicious and always served on time with great customer service

Let me see Why your so despret | Oct 14, 2018
Racheal J | Oct 14, 2018

I was there January of this year 2018 and their crabcakes are to kill for! So delicious!

Read More

Does Sammys deliver?

Lesan Edwards | Oct 14, 2018
keith roan | Oct 14, 2018

I dont think so but if you go there you"ll keep going back again and again ,you"ll be in seafood Heaven

Read More

Do you have a special meal for lunch

Adventure's With Denise And Mary | Oct 14, 2018
Raul MacBeth | Oct 14, 2018

Yes a good variety.

Read More

How much is stuffed twin lobster tails

Cisco Soares | Oct 14, 2018
Cisco Soares | Oct 14, 2018

I found out..it was starting at 42.99, and goes up depending on the type of stuffing you choose.. Thanks

Read More

Do u have Mister on the menu?

Ruben Jimenez | Oct 14, 2017
Ruben Jimenez | Oct 14, 2017

Do u have Loster plate?

Read More

How long have they been in business

Tracey Jones | Oct 14, 2017
saf K | Oct 14, 2017

Since 1966.... Going there for 27 years now.. Still great..

Read More

The food is good but very expensive for 4 shrimp and some potatoes they charge very expensive ?????

Dj Ivan Carrion (i) | Jul 15, 2022
Tracey Thompson | Jul 15, 2022

Yes, the food was good, so I guess that's the reason for the high cost. The portion was big so I took some food home

Read More

How do you make a complaint

Kiesha Vanderburg | Oct 13, 2021
Tavia Tay | Oct 13, 2021

A bad review would be the best option

Read More

I was told Sammys does all you can eat crab legs but didn’t see anything on the website suggesting they do. Anyone know if they do?

Rob Sanicola | Oct 13, 2021
Elizabeth Luciany | Oct 13, 2021

No they do not have all you can eat crab legs. They have snow and king crab legs platter with shrimp or scallops or individual. Try the king crab legs very meaty. The cornbread and loaf of bread is delicious before the meal.

Read More

Is there a picture of how the outdoor dining is?

Carmen Adorno | Oct 13, 2020
Frank Baez | Oct 13, 2020

No

Read More

How can I purchase a gift card

Anita Leacock | Oct 13, 2020
Denise Vargas | Oct 13, 2020

I don't think they do gift cards. They have an online ordering service but I prefer to just go and pick up the food as it also serves as an opportunity for sightseeing within the local neighborhood. You can access the on-line ordering on their website: order.sammysfishbox.com

Read More

Please switch to another takeout app. I wasted 2 hours trying to order from the app after I was told I couldn’t through the phone. I was never able to place the order and had to restart my order after every failed attempt.

Yaneisa Pagan | Oct 13, 2020
Eddie Rivera | Oct 13, 2020

Go in person . That's what we did. You order at the take out window. Park across the street. And they bring you your order. It took 20 minutes

does sammy's do large catering events?

Tony Felton | Oct 13, 2020
Erica Hitchgraham | Oct 13, 2020

You should call Sammy's

Read More

Do you use Grub Hub???

Lollie Singleton | Oct 14, 2019
Troy Tolbert | Oct 14, 2019

I Believe you have to drive there

Read More

what is the dress code

melvin williams | Oct 14, 2019
Cathedral Perkins | Oct 14, 2019

casual

Read More

do they accept credit cards

john Skarka | Oct 14, 2019
K “mrs.k.o.88” O'Mealley | Oct 14, 2019

Yes

Read More

Do they have seating outside

Kenyetta Duncan | Oct 14, 2019
Liseli P. | Oct 14, 2019

We were at the fish box and it did not appear to have outdoor seating. The one accross the street did have outdoor seating tho

Read More

How is the food?

david grate | Oct 14, 2019
Deron Dunn | Oct 14, 2019

Great food. Definately going back.

Read More

Are you open in September

Jasmine Lewis | Oct 14, 2019
Greg | Oct 14, 2019

Strange question. Sammy is open all year round.

Read More

Do you do credit cards

Carmen Colon | Oct 14, 2019
O G King Blood | Oct 14, 2019

YEAH

Read More

Do they serve Dungeness crab?

P N | Oct 14, 2019
Anita Lowndes | Oct 14, 2019

I didn't see it on the menu

Read More

Can you bring a birthday cake to be cut while or after dining?

Saeeda Ra'nee | Oct 14, 2019
Carlos Sanchez | Oct 14, 2019

I am sure it would be possible, but always call and ask before showing up with the cake. managers are individuals, so while some may others may not. Calling and making arrangements before hand is wise.

Read More

are you open tomorrow on December 25

Vladimir Demine | Oct 14, 2019
Pypr pronounced Piper | Oct 14, 2019

They usually are til 1 am 2 am on weekends

Read More

My fiancée is allergic to seafood but I love it, do they have a separate meñu that’s not seafood?

Domingo Torres | Oct 14, 2018
Josef Massias | Oct 14, 2018

Yes they do.

Read More

Do they have senior discount?

Gloria Stephney | Oct 14, 2018
Denal Jones | Oct 14, 2018

Don't know but it's better for you to go on the website.

Read More

Do they have outdoor seating

George Kokoros | Oct 14, 2018
Maylen Santos | Oct 14, 2018

Np but Sammy's Fish Box across the street does. It has parking and great service as well.

Read More

Do they have a kids menu??

Diana Tahuico | Oct 14, 2018
the boss the fox | Oct 14, 2018

Yes they do. Kids menu is awesome.

Read More

Do you need reservations for Mother's Day

Alicia ferrell | Oct 14, 2018
MARLENE COBB | Oct 14, 2018

Mother's Day , SAMMY'S will be packed, so I would definitely call and make reservations.

Read More

Does Sammys work with Uber?

Michael Berry | Oct 14, 2018
Brian Roberts | Oct 14, 2018

No uber eats doesnt do sammys but u can search within the app

Read More

Do they accommodate bus rides do they have a prefix menu? Anybody????

Lashonda Bronson | Oct 14, 2018
Ngari Cadogan | Oct 14, 2018

Yes they do have the accommodation

Read More

Is The Outside Patio By Water ?

Dom G | Oct 14, 2018
John | Oct 14, 2018

No

Read More

What time will Sammy's open today, MLK?

Stephanie Culbreth | Oct 14, 2018
rosalina feliciano | Oct 14, 2018

11am but you can call them

Read More

Will you be opened on Monday December 25, 2017

Carlton Knight | Oct 14, 2018
Richie Rich | Oct 14, 2018

They are scheduled to be open 11:30 AM to 3 AM but hours may differ on Christmas Eve and Christmas day. I would call them directly to inquire.

Read More

How much is the platter

Dianne Copeland | Oct 14, 2018
Anthony Goodsell | Oct 14, 2018

Expect $50+ not worth it. Go somewhere cool. Not this poorly decorated, overpriced seafood restaurant. I suggest "the original Crab shanty" in the middle of main street. You'll get more food and it has a more relaxed vibe. Always packed though!!

Read More

How do u make that veg platter?

Liz Hicks | Oct 14, 2018
Gregory Thomas | Oct 14, 2018

Honestly liz,i dont know.

How much for lobster legs

Blanca Fuentes | Oct 14, 2018
Ritesh Nair | Oct 14, 2018

Our lobster came overcooked and salty. There were five of us, and I spent over $400. I think Crab Shanty is better

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places