Terry's Pizza Shoppe

Dana Lasko

Quite possibly THE worst pizza I've ever had. We ordered a large deluxe. It had a super thin crust, very little sauce and I don't think they even purl cheese on it. Thank goodness it at least had onions and banana peppers on it because that was the only flavor that it had. Needless to say we won't be ordering pizza from there again. I gave it 2 stars (instead of 1) because we had their chicken & JoJo's a couple of weeks ago and that was very good. We would get the chicken & JoJo's again. Pizza...never!

Bobbi Croft

Very pleasant atmosphere, wonderful employees and great food!

Tammy James

I wish I had the same experience as the other reviews. Whoever the woman was at the counter treated me like the very sight of me made her mad. I've never been to Terry's pizza before and I had just finished at my Dr appointment in newcomerstown and I was starving. I walked in and before I could even get to the counter she blurts out..." You got a pickup?!" I'm hard hearing so I said " what's that?" She said with a scowl, " you got a pickup?!" I said " oh, no, do you guys have pizza already made?" Long story short, she made me feel like a fool for asking and continued to tell me how they don't even have the buffet anymore because of the epidemic. I said...oh no, really? Actually just trying to make conversation. She said...." WELL.... TURN AROUND!!! Cause the buffet was behind me empty. I felt humiliated and said ok, thank you and walked out.

Marty Mccune

I have always loved going to Terry's and have been doing so since I was 11. Friendly staff and clean, happy atmosphere. Definitely a place with hometown feel, and owned by a local family that helps the community and helps make the experience always great.