Stagecoach Inn

Category: American restaurant

Address: 6396 County Line Rd, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538, USA

Phone: +16088683850

Opening hours

Sunday: 3:30–9PM

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 4:30–9PM

Wednesday: 4:30–9PM

Thursday: 4:30–9PM

Friday: 4:30–10PM

Saturday: 4:15–10PM

Reviews

Don Dearinger

Jun 16, 2022

I have been here a few times while visiting friends nearby. The vibe is great! Friendly staff with a supper club vibe. Everybody is social and welcoming. The food is traditional steak house fare. On my part visit I had the ribeye special which was outstanding! Good, cocktails, great staff and wonderful food. I'll come back!

M Wachter

May 21, 2022

First time visit tonight. Our server. Jamie, was excellent! The drinks, food and dessert were all fabulous. Great atmosphere, easy to get to and hard working staff. Everyone helps each other out and their service was flawless. Shout out to Jamie, she made the experience wonderful! Will definitely return!

Becky Saliby

Jan 10, 2022

We had a fantastic time on our 1st stop for our 22 Supper Clubs in 2022 tour. Atmosphere is warm and welcoming, service was fast and friendly and the bacon wrapped filet, to die for.! Highly recommend!!

tisha morgan

Aug 14, 2021

Had gone a few weeks ago, party of 5, and was pleased with service and food with the exception of the relish tower. Made reservation and returned again expecting a similar experience and was deeply disappointed and infuriated. Seated in the "game room" which is an area approximately 8X10 with video poker machines and littered with empty booze boxes and extra chairs. Basically a storage area! The very small high top table was adorned with 3 paper placemats. We were an afterthought! Service was apparently considered an annoyance on the part of the staff. Appetizer of onion rings, all 4 of them, arrived with a squeeze bottle of ketchup. Found out later that the onion rings had been spilled and that was what was left. Had to ask for salt and pepper 3 times, 1 order baked onion soup was forgotten with the excuse that the oven couldn't accommodate the soups ordered. We had to clear the disgusting relish tray from the tiny table to the top of stack of discarded booze boxes on the floor. When we couldn't abide the experience any longer we asked to see the owner. 10 minutes later someone, not the owner, showed up only to be dismissive. The owner, 15 minutes later, showed up only to raise his voice, complained about another party holding up another table, and said he was "holding back his anger" and announced he had sweaty armpits. Seriously! We stood up, requested a bill immediately for what we has consumed thus far and left. NEVER WILL WE RETURN AND NEVER WILL RECOMMEND THIS S%#& SHOW TO ANYONE! Apparently by the owner's response his recollection of who interrupted who is lacking. How about never expecting a customer to be crammed in a littered storage area. How about calling customer ahead when you saw a table traffic jam in process. How about explaining the mismanaged seating dilemma upon our arrival.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

does it have good stakes

chrisann herda | Apr 30, 2019
Gordon Cooper | May 1, 2019

Does a cat purr! Excellent Steaks.

Read More

Do you have Friday night fish fry?

Todd Schneider | Apr 29, 2020
Robert Guyer | Apr 30, 2020

Yes, the best. You need 5 people to make reservations. Otherwise, get there early they open at 4.

Read More

Are you open on Sundays

Janet Johnson | Apr 29, 2020
Stagecoach Inn (Owner) | Apr 30, 2020

Yes!!!

Do you take credit cards or cash only

Pam Pacholczak | Apr 30, 2019
Kathleen Keller | May 1, 2019

They take credit cards. Excellent food.

Read More

Does the Stagecoach have t-shirts ?

Mike Heilman | Apr 8, 2022
Randy Cole | Apr 9, 2022

I did not see any type of clothing for sale when I was there.

Read More

Do you have mothers day brunch?

Lori Dathan | Jun 3, 2021
Stagecoach Inn (Owner) | Jun 4, 2021

Hello! We open at 10AM on Mother's Day with full menu! For reservations please call 608-868-3850 ❤

Are they open on Christmas eve

Mona L | Apr 29, 2020
Steven Feltes | Apr 30, 2020

Call

When are you reopening?

Toni Hulick | Apr 30, 2019
Gwendalyn Kienbaum | May 1, 2019

They are open again.

Are they handicap accessible ?

Micky Key | Apr 30, 2019
Thomas Rauman | May 1, 2019

Yes

Read More

Are they open during construction

Angela Geer | Apr 30, 2019
Thomas Rauman | May 1, 2019

Yes

Do they have Salad bar or relish tray

Shirley Kohls | Apr 30, 2019
Guy Sterrett | May 1, 2019

Relish tray...no salad bar

Are there any specials for mothers day.

Richard Pausch | Apr 30, 2019
Sean Shinkay | May 1, 2019

Full menu plus prime rib and our steak and shrimp specials!

Read More

What nights do they serve the prime rib?

Scott Diederich | Apr 30, 2018
Terry Healy | May 1, 2018

Their food is great but the further reason to go is the sense of hospitality that starts with the owner and continues throughout the entire staff. A truly pleasant dining experence.

Read More

do you have an Easter buffet on April 1 2018.

susan thomas | Apr 30, 2018
Brian Jira | May 1, 2018

I concur. They are not set up to do a buffet and there's a good chance they are not open Easter Sunday. You'd have to call to be sure. Good is fantastic if you go. They may have my favorite Ribeye!

Read More

Do you have crab legs? Or butterfly shrimp?

julie ramminger | Apr 30, 2018
Larry Harlow | May 1, 2018

Great old fashions and food is great as well.

Read More

Are reservations required?

Michele Brown | Apr 30, 2018
c amphicar | May 1, 2018

Reservations are not required but this is a smaller quaint excellent restaurant which makes it extremely popular..even with reservations you will not be guaranteed a table when you arrive..dining is excellent and worth the wait!

Read More

Will you be open Christmas eve?

Jeff DePietro | Apr 30, 2018
Steve Sathre | May 1, 2018

Nobody answered you I just saw your question.I would have to say no

Will you be open Christmas Day

M an G TV | Apr 30, 2018
Jared Stutz | May 1, 2018

Highly doubt it. Dont count on it

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places