Five Pennies Creamery

Category: Ice cream shop

Address: 11 N Park Ave, Rockville Centre, NY 11570, USA

Phone: +15166084344

Opening hours

Sunday: 1–9:30PM

Monday: 3–9:30PM

Tuesday: 2–9:30PM

Wednesday: 2–9:30PM

Thursday: 2–9:30PM

Friday: 2–10PM

Saturday: 1–10PM

Reviews

Nikhil Muzumdar

Sep 5, 2022

This is my favorite local spot. Reminds me of a new England style old-school ice cream place and you can't go wrong no matter the flavor you choose!

Miguelina Herrera

Sep 2, 2022

Delicious ice cream

ALI KHAN

Aug 23, 2022

Best ice cream I had after a while. Better than cold stone

Azelia Ng

Aug 15, 2022

Decor could use sprucing but the ice cream was good. Banana is hard to find and they had banana pudding!

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Named after? Red & the five pennies?

Gillian Andersen | Mar 10, 2022
Five Pennies Creamery | Apr 9, 2022

Yes! We are named after the film The Five Pennies. Danny Kaye plays the role of Red Nichols.

Read More

What are Saturday hours you are open?

Peggy Lee | Jan 9, 2022
Chris Coen | Jan 9, 2022

9:30pm

Do they still have icecream pies?

The Ghoulish One | Oct 6, 2021
Zach Zanghi | Oct 6, 2021

Yeah they regularly carry some. They also take customer orders

Do they make sure people with allegeriges are safe

jessica caraballo | Oct 7, 2018
Dee Mocha | Oct 7, 2018

I'm not sure. They do not have a list of all of their ingredients posted but if you ask what is in a particular flavor they will tell you.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places