II Tomato

Natalie Thompson

First time going and waited 1 hour and 45 minutes for food. I wanted to go in back and just fix my.own food. Then it comes out and it's luke warm. Waitress,Heather, forgot our drink orders a couple times. Just not a good first impression.

Marc Suber

I Just djayed here yesterday, and wow it was amazing! Stunning Atmosphere, the food was absolutely amazing! Don't even get me started about the staff! They were all amazing and absolutely wonderful to work with! I can't wait to play here again!

Yetemar-Kenyell Cross

New Castle is distinctively blessed to have so many local eateries and friendly people all over the town. I came here for the first time, and saw a more fanciful, nicely done interior than expected. It’s where you can go for a nice night out, or simply a nice evening dinner. The Meatball Risotto appetizer was delicious. The pictures didn’t do my Chicken Vincenzo entree justice. The portion was so plentiful, I had another full meal to take home. I recommend this place and the support of local restaurants. Audrey was a great server. Their herbed olive oil is also great; I wanted to pour it over everything.

Ruri Sacchini

I can't say enough about this place. First off its beautiful inside. The waitress was super friendly and very helpful. Everything we had was amazing! We had the smelts which were the best smelts we've ever had which is saying a lot! They had a great fresh taste and there wasn't a drop of oil/grease on your fingers so good! If you want a great artisan pizza you need to go here! All the pizza are brick oven baked which makes a huge difference. So much flavor! I just feel like this place doesn't get the recognition that it deserves. Seriously give it a try!