Buffalo Nickel Inc

Category: Pizza restaurant

Address: 57 Pebbly Beach Rd, Avalon, CA 90704, USA

Phone: +13105101323

Opening hours

Sunday: 10AM–9PM

Monday: 11AM–9PM

Tuesday: 11AM–9PM

Wednesday: 11AM–9PM

Thursday: 11AM–9PM

Friday: 11AM–9PM

Saturday: 10AM–9PM

Reviews

Megan M

Sep 27, 2022

Local gem of Avalon; not commercialized like much of the island, but still outstanding service, food, and drinks! I’ve had the local namesake “Buffalo Milk” at a couple of different restaurants, but this one is my favorite! Also highly recommend the ceviche and calamari!

Leslie S (SprtnGrrl)

Sep 21, 2022

Lorenzo! The food, guide service, and bartending was amazing. Ceviche is a must. We will be back!

John McGhee

Sep 16, 2022

A hidden gem. For those that fly via iex helicopters, this place is awesome. Free shuttle to Avalon. So drink, eat, be merry! Just know that pretty aggressive bees and wasps will want your food during the summer months outside. They don't sting. But they annoy. July to September. Eat inside. Other months, outside.

Tony Munoz

Sep 12, 2022

Good food

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

Anonymous | Sep 28, 2022
Eric King | Sep 28, 2021

Eating is outside. Wear a mask only while not at the table.

Read More

Do you offer a delivery service?

Mark Kats | Sep 29, 2018
C.T. H | Sep 29, 2018

After 5 oclock they take delivery orders

Read More

Buffalo nickel is a must see restaurant in the island and the Buffalo milk drink is the one of a kind ,make sure that Agustin makes it for you he is a Pro master mixer!!😀🙂🤩

Toby Toby | Dec 2, 2021
Jerry Mullins | Dec 2, 2021

I have been to this place before on previous trips to Catalina. I went here last week with a group of friends on 10/27/21. We decided to meet and we were the only people outside. Service was very very slow to get our. They brought bottled water to our table and charges $3.75 per bottle. Out of all the places we ate at Avalon they were the only ones to bring bottled water and charges the outrageous amount! The waiter did not want to take the water back. Next it took a long time to get her food you would think the place was packed. Our original waiter drop the menus and we never saw him again. They refused to take her order for each couple and put it on one bill. This made it very difficult for us to pay for our meal!! We had to break the bill down ourselves and that was a pain. We all like to give a generous tip but they made sure they put it in the bill and I know that is common in some places! Don't waste your time!

Will you pick up at our hotel? Catalina inn..cause its raining

Samantha Brown Aston | Sep 29, 2018
Ed Gold | Sep 29, 2018

Call them... they might??

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places