Cimaroli's Supper Club

Category: Restaurant in Portage, Wisconsin

Address: W11793 WI-127, Portage, WI 53901, USA

Phone: +16087422238

Opening hours

Sunday: 4–9PM

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 4–9PM

Wednesday: 4–9PM

Thursday: 4–9PM

Friday: 4–10PM

Saturday: 4–10PM

Reviews

Raymond Wong

Jul 13, 2022

The flat iron steak is amazingly tender and delicious. Their fried shrimp side was also perfectly cooked. The only recommendations I would make a would be to ask for your steak a step more rare, since it keeps cooking on the sizzling plate, and for them to swap out their margarine-based garlic "butter" for real butter.

Franklin Fletcher

Jun 18, 2022

We had an excellent dinner experience. Showed up around 4 PM, relaxed in the bar with drinks, which were generous and delicious. Then at dinner, the prime rib was outstanding and the barbecue pork ribs were very good (maybe just a bit dry). The service was world class in the lounge and at our dinner table. I wish I could remember the server’s name. There was a genuine “supper club“ feel to the place because we met so many friendly people. We plan to go back tomorrow night, which is only three nights after our first visit.

Julie Ann Krueger

Apr 23, 2022

Excellent food and friendly service! Onion ring appetizer, husband had prime rib, and I had pasta sauce all had a great flavor. Including the rolls. Definitely would go back.

Michael Grills

Feb 4, 2022

After driving from Chicago to our hotel in Portage we had a hankering for a nice Steak dinner, so we did what your doing now (Googled local steak joints) and after reading a bunch of reviews, we settled on Cimaroli's and I'm glad we did! …

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

What's your menus.?

Kally Ryan | Feb 25, 2018
Frank Abela | Feb 26, 2018

Italian, excellent flat iron steak!!

Can you bring children

Leeann Burchett | Feb 25, 2020
Garrett Galen | Feb 26, 2020

Yes, children are welcome. Just know it will get busy on the weekends!

Read More

Do they take reservations?

Mary Wesh | Feb 25, 2018
Heidi Hadac | Feb 26, 2018

No

Read More

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

People are asking | Feb 24, 2021
Kathleen Genz | Feb 25, 2021

Families are spaced away from other families. I think they do a good job regarding the safety protocol.

Read More

Can I make reservation?

Dennis davis | Feb 25, 2020
Elbia Hernandez | Feb 26, 2020

No

Read More

How is the roasted duck?

Sandy Mueller | Feb 25, 2020
Mary N. | Feb 26, 2020

Sorry I've never had their duck. Only eaten their flat iron steak which is flavorful & a bit chewy.

Read More

What is excepted for payment??

Heidi Mierzejewski | Oct 27, 2021
Craig Anderson | Oct 28, 2021

Cash or card is fine! Enjoy!

Are they still in business? I have been told that they closed.

allan sheets | Jun 29, 2021
Bryan Siltman | Jun 30, 2021

I was there 1 week ago as well. It was open for business with no signs of closing.

Read More

Do they have a military discount ?

Peter Statz | Feb 25, 2020
rick grobner | Feb 26, 2020

Pretty sure not

Read More

Do they take credit cards?

Kathleen Lippert | Feb 25, 2020
Kris Meier | Feb 26, 2020

Yes

Read More

Do they take reservations for 2

Jason Vredeveld | Feb 25, 2019
Molly Stahl | Feb 26, 2019

No reservations at all. Go early :) otherwise the wait is usually 1-2 hours. The $2.50 old Fashioneds help the wait!

Read More

What is included in the Friday Night Senior Fish Fry? Do you open your doors at 4:00 or start serving at 4:00 pm.

Connie Hawkins | Feb 25, 2020
Marjorie Margelowsky | Feb 26, 2020

What days are you closed?

Read More

Will they be open on thanksgiving?

Lance Ferry | Feb 25, 2019
Gus Schroeder | Feb 26, 2019

Dont know you will have to call

Do you still get to order 6 fried shrimp to go with your steak for 3.99

judy granger | Feb 25, 2019
Heather P | Feb 26, 2019

Probably best to call for that answer.

Are you open Easter Sunday?

Betty D | Feb 25, 2019
missy bablick | Feb 26, 2019

Sorry no idea

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places