Sift Bake Shop Mystic

Category: Bakery in Mystic, Stonington, CT

Address: 5 Water St, Mystic, CT 06355, USA

Phone: +18602450541

Opening hours

Sunday: 7AM–7PM

Monday: 7AM–7PM

Tuesday: 7AM–7PM

Wednesday: 7AM–7PM

Thursday: 7AM–7PM

Friday: 7AM–7PM

Saturday: 7AM–7PM

Reviews

Cynthia McCarthy

Sep 27, 2022

Not happy with 2/3rds of my purchase. Postive-the cream filled almond croissant was delicious. The lemon curd in my macron was delicious, although the macron was disintegrated and practically non existent. The coconut macron was delicious. The coconut vanilla fillen macron was too sweet and bland and very little coconut flavor. The cookies I bought were average at best. First time there and very disappointed for almost $30 of not good quality desserts. Just being honest.

Stephen Whitehouse

Sep 22, 2022

Overpriced pastry.

Zachary Perrin

Sep 21, 2022

Best bakery around.

Claire Herritz

Sep 13, 2022

I had an amazing almond milk coconut/almond flavored iced latte and a ham and cheese croissant. The best iced coffee I’ve ever had.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

how much is buche de noel roll?

Beatrice Flanagan | Sep 26, 2020
Sift Bake Shop Mystic | Sep 26, 2021

Hi Beatrice! Sorry we missed seeing this and we apologize for the excessive delay. We do have the buche de noel every Christmas holiday. For the future, it is $44 and serves up to 12 guests. Warmly- Ebbie

What flavor macaroons do you have

robert myers | Sep 26, 2020
Sift Bake Shop Mystic | Sep 26, 2020

Hello Robert- Thanks for the question! Our macaron flavors vary by season and day- as they are all made by hand and from scratch. Generally, our most popular flavors are: chocolate, vanilla, pistachio, rose water, lemon, PB & J, coconut, and so on. We also offer seasonal flavors like apple pie and pumpkin chai. Again- these are just a sampling of flavors, but we do our best to keep these in stock. Hope to see you! Best- Ebbie Young, Owner

Read More

Does Sift bake bread?

Peter Fazio | Sep 27, 2019
Sift Bake Shop Mystic | Sep 27, 2019

Hi Peter! Thanks for the question! We do indeed make fresh bread every day, using a slow fermentation process. Currently we offer about five varieties, and our offerings do change seasonally. In addition, for the best selection and variety, we suggest coming earlier in the day, as the breads can sell-out on weekends. We hope to welcome you! Warmly- Ebbie Young

Read More

Are you open christmas eve?

Martine Nolletti | Sep 27, 2018
Sift Bake Shop Mystic | Sep 26, 2021

Yes! 7-7! Very sorry for the delay, but better late than never. Sorry again!

Read More

Do they have cheese danishes?

svariato svariato | Sep 27, 2018
Sift Bake Shop Mystic | Sep 27, 2018

Hello Svariato- Sorry for the delay in seeing this. Currently we have a pumpkin cheese danish for the fall! Hope to see you!- Ebbie & Adam Young Also Charlie Belinski- to answer your question (below), Sift was just a name we embraced that captured the theme of baking. We appreciate the kind words on the new Watch Hill Shop, and will hope to see you there again soon, thanks so much!- Ebbie Also- At this time we use the cheese danish as a seasonal flavor, so soon it will be pumpkin and cheese! :)

Read More

Do you make bagettes

Kathy Seitz | Jul 28, 2022
Sift Bake Shop Mystic | Jul 28, 2022

Hi Kathy! Yes, we do make fresh, home made baguettes daily, along with a variety of other scratch made breads. hope to see you!

Do you make baguettes loaves?

Kathy Seitz | Jul 28, 2022
Sift Bake Shop Mystic | Jul 28, 2022

Hi Kathy! Unfortunately, we do not make our baguettes into loaves!

are you open on Sunday?

Marji Kochis | Feb 28, 2022
Sift Bake Shop Mystic | Feb 28, 2022

Hi there! We are open every day from 7-7 and offer extended hours in the summer. We only close for Easter, Thanksgiving and Christmas. Hope to see you!

Read More

Is rooftop open today?

david slater | Oct 31, 2021
Ryan Kepley | Nov 30, 2021

Yes

Read More

Do you make gluten free birthday cakes?

Gail Orsi | Sep 26, 2021
Denise Zelman T. | Sep 26, 2021

You should maybe call them and ask.

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

Anonymous | Sep 26, 2022
Sift Bake Shop Mystic | Sep 26, 2021

Thank you for asking! COVID protocol is taken very seriously- as is overall safety & sanitation. We have always cleaned & sanitized regularly, so COVID is no exception & we continue to do so on an increased basis & strict schedule. Currently we have a plexiglass barrier to keep guests separated while in line. In addition, our staff wear and replace their gloves, wear masks & wash hands frequently. We are also very strict about mask wearing. Guests are kindly asked to leave if they will not wear a mask (nose covered) inside. We also sign the iPad for the guests if they prefer, to limit the number of guests touching screens. We consistently monitor staff & encourage frequent testing to be proactive. Last, a limited number of guests are permitted inside & six feet social distancing is enforced by the team. Overall, safety & unparalleled cleanliness in a welcoming environment is our goal. Our integrity as a business depends on proper enforcement of these important community values.

Do you ship items?

Dale Noble | Sep 26, 2020
Ebbie Young | Sep 26, 2020

Hi Dale- I regret we do not ship or offer delivery, but appreciate your interest and hope to welcome you soon! Warmly, Ebbie Young, Owner

Do they ship

Adrian Williams | Sep 26, 2020
Sift Bake Shop Mystic | Sep 26, 2020

Hi Adrian- Thank you for the message. I regret we don’t ship or offer delivery at this time. Happy Holidays!

Read More

Do you make Italian bread

Karen Jackson | Sep 26, 2020
Sift Bake Shop Mystic | Sep 26, 2020

Thanks for the question Karen! We do not make Italian bread, but we do offer a variety if artisanal breads as G Webb kindly noted. We offer focaccia, baguettes, pain d' epi, and brioche specials. We also make seasonal ciabattas as well. All of our breads are made from scratch and by hand with love. Hope to see you! Best- Ebbie Young, Owner

Read More

Do you ship croissants to Jersey

Doreen Robertson | Sep 26, 2020
Sift Bake Shop Mystic | Sep 26, 2020

Hi Doreen- Many thanks for the question! I regret we don't offer any shipping or delivery services at this time. Hope to see you soon! Best- Ebbie

Read More

Do you have any Keto friendly baked goods or cake?

Tracy Whitehead | Sep 27, 2019
Demetrios Kanavaros | Sep 27, 2019

If you're on a keto diet, you probably shouldn't even be thinking of eating desserts.

Read More

Do you make hard rolls ?

Eddie Elkins | Sep 27, 2019
Fabby Vazquez | Sep 27, 2019

They have baguettes, and delicious croissants, everything is so delicious!

Read More

When are u open What are your hours, it doesn’t say

Juliana Provenzano | Sep 27, 2019
Sift Bake Shop Mystic | Sep 27, 2019

Hello Juliana- Thanks for the question! Currently, (May 13th, 2019) Sift Mystic is closed to complete our renovations through next Thursday, May 23rd, 2019. Otherwise we are open every day from 7-7, with extended evening hours in the summer. Our sister store in Watch Hill, RI is open daily starting this Thursday, May 16th, 2019 from 8-close. Hope to see you! - Ebbie Young

Do they sell cupcakes?

Jennifer Cowett | Sep 27, 2019
Sift Bake Shop Mystic | Sep 27, 2019

Hi Jennifer- Thanks for the question! Unfortunately, we do not make cupcakes. We are more of a French focussed bakery, so we offer desserts with a European flair! Hope that helps, and hope to see you soon for some other treats! Best- Ebbie Young

Read More

Do you do eggs and pancakes?

Karen Cannady | Sep 27, 2018
Harriette Clark | Sep 27, 2018

No

Read More

Do you accept Mystic dollars?

Diane Stump | Sep 27, 2018
Sindi Mannochi | Sep 27, 2018

Worth checking out if your in the Mystic area. Adam the owner just won best baker in America!

Read More

Do they make anything sugar free??

Pam Buffinton | Sep 27, 2018
Sift Bake Shop Mystic | Sep 27, 2018

Hi Pam, Thanks for the question. At this time, we don't have sugar-free items, but we do have a variety of Gluten-Free items, and some vegan items as well. We will hope to see you, thank you! - Ebbie Young

Read More

Do you bake any gluten free breads or pastries?

Lois Pettit | Sep 27, 2018
Tracy McKay | Sep 27, 2018

They sure do. Just not bread. Everything here is delicious!

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places