OId Fields Barbecue Setauket

Grace Marie

Review update 2022 July: revisited to check out the new menu that is Oldfields Tavern. The selection is outstanding, there's items on the menu for everyone nothing that we ordered fell short of fantastic. Burratta, spicy feta dip, birria pork tacos, fried green tomatoes, and one of my favorites the cookie butter bread pudding. Seriously amazing. Full of flavor and everything was hot, fresh and plated impeccably. Can't wait to revisit with friends and family. Food here is great! Staff was super friendly and inviting, drinks and food came quickly. Owner brought out a few slices of cobbler for us to finish off a great meal! We will be returning. Highly recommend to anyone.

elena saunders

Hands down the best BBQ spot on the island. Everything and I mean everything that was served to me was fall off the bone perfection. Delicious every single last bite. The fried chicken was the crispiest and most juicy piece of chicken I've ever had. The brisket was moist and the ribs finger licking good. Don't get me started on those collard greens, those mashed potatoes, or that cornbread. WOW JUST WOW. If you haven't eaten here yet you need to go no questions asked head over there now. God truly gifted that chefs hands because he is incredible!!!!

Sal Verdi

I’ve had bbq all over the United States and this will beat most southern bbq.The ribs and brisket were perfect .super tender and perfect amount of smoke flavor . Kudos to let the meat shine with not adding sauce on them . True fashion . Hands down best bbq on Long Island . Can’t wait to eat here again

Candita Erler

Love this place, especially the bartender Deanna! She makes us feel at home and always has a delicious cocktail up her sleeve! Looking forward to stopping in for a yummy treat, can’t wait to try something new.Thank you, Candita! We appreciate the review! Come back and see us soon!