Mellie's New York Deli & Eatery

Stuart Stadler

Horrible and over priced! How do you burn then send out a pancake! The bagel was burnt, eggs over cooked to death, and all tasted horrible! The people here don’t seem to care as no one was here when making 1 simple order!

Peter Urbanek

Very disappointed. We were really looking forward to our first visit. The restaurant was not the cleanest. The cook put her bare hand into the coleslaw to put on my sandwich while touching everything else in the place. The Yank sandwich was …Peter, I am so sorry about your experience. Our Yankee is served on grilled marble rye and corned beef is known as salted beef, maybe try the pastrami next time. Our side salads are all made in house and the potato salad is our most popular side item. We would love for you to give us another try with the meal on us. Again we are sorry.

Rachel Withers

So I’m giving five stars because I love this place but I had to write a review in hopes it gets to the owners. My husband ordered this for me and he said over the phone “nova salmon bagel” there’s a young girl taking our order maybe around …Hi Rachel! We appreciate you and your review. I re read this a few times and do not worry, our nova lox will always have our McKnight Nova, Tomatoes, Onions and Capers Atop our bagel with shmear! I am so sorry with the phone order experience you had, and thank you for bringing this to my attention. Hope to see you and your husband soon!