Donny's Girl Supper Club

cindy carle

Service was very good. That’s where the good ended. We used to frequent Donnys girl often under previous owners and it was always fantastic. We decided to try it tonight for the first time under the new owners. I ordered prime rib that was inedible. And I am not picky about food at all. I sent it back once because it was purple and bloody and so tough I couldn’t even cut it. Came back with outside more done but inside still so bloody. And I like rare prime rib. I should’ve said more but didn’t want to make a scene. Our waitress was very kind so we paid and left. Also the seasoning on everything was so overpowering. Not sure if it was thyme or rosemary. It was on everything. My husbands fish was not great either. Salad bar was good. Very disappointed tonight

Casper Linder

Have not been there since the new ownership took over earlier this year. Stopped by to get 2 fish dinners to go and an appetizer which was cheese curds. ordered the fish dinners with soup. When I got home and inspected the food, I noticed the soup was not there. We were supposed to get five pieces of fish each, one dinner only had four. The fish pieces were small and somewhat overcooked. The French fries were undercooked and soggy. The sides that came with the dinner were a joke, you got coleslaw and potato salad. They only gave literally 1 tablespoon of each, we measured it. The cheese curds you only received about 9 and they were very greasy, not worth what I paid for them. I will say the staff was friendly. We have been going to this place for a long time and the food was always good. Definitely a drastic decline in food quality, not what I expected from this place I thought so highly of. I have never left a review before, but I felt I had to this time. It's not to try and hurt the business but to help it. I hope management takes this constructive criticism to improve the quality of the food to the standards that Donny's Girl has been known for and what I have been enjoying since I moved to Watertown in 2005.

Don Wilks

Service was average, I went in with my family ordered our dinner, and sodas for all of us, and never was told that they charge $2.00 for each refill. Not happy! For an additional $3.95 if ordered with a meal they tell you only ONE trip to the salad bar, and the plate they give you to use is small. They charge you a convenience charge of 4% for any credit card use, and never told us.There was no sign where you said it was. Nice try turning the tables on your customer stating I am a liar. The only businesses that charge this are the ones struggling with this ridiculous surge charge. Hmm... If you want people to return, maybe be a cash only. Must be a sign behind the bar, and the host station that we charge $2.00 for each refill for soda as well hey? Wrong no sign. If you want to pay more for less then this is your place.

Jillian yeske

A short wait at the bar sipping on an excellent, brandy, old-fashioned sweet. We ordered at the table executed perfectly by our wonderful waitress, Judie! Way too much food, but all in all worth the 40-minute drive! P.S. I highly recommend the margarita wine 👌