Elias Inn Supper Club

Category: Bar

Address: 200 N 2nd St, Watertown, WI 53094, USA

Phone: +19202616262

Opening hours

Sunday: Closed

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: Closed

Wednesday: 4:30–9PM

Thursday: 4:30–9PM

Friday: 4–9PM

Saturday: 4:30–9PM

Reviews

Cameron Rankin

Jul 25, 2022

Elias Inn has a great environment, and has a great German-American supper club feel. The steak was phenomenal, and the shrimp was decent. We had to wait a little long imo, and it was a little loud, but otherwise a great place for a nice dinner. We look forward to returning to the Elias Inn Supper Club sometime soon.

Jo Goralski

Jul 8, 2022

I heard on the grapevine that the Elias Inn was new, but still its good old self. I ordered the stuffed shrimp, and they were incredible. Old school flavors without heavy breading. When my husband snagged a bite, he closed his eyes in delight. He had the stroganoff, which was the other item I wanted to order. I grabbed the first bite, and it was perfect. So tender, and tasty, and spaetzle in my favorite shape. The Old Fashions were perfect. The whole evening was wonderful. Thank you for saving such a beloved place.

Candy Tuler

Jun 19, 2022

I was at Elias Inn Saturday night under new ownership. Dinner room was freezing! Lazy Suzy the same, salad not so much, had to ask twice for extra cheese and croutons. Dinner, prime rib and lobster. Not even close to the flavors of the past. Wishing them the best but didn't have John Elias's touch. I know I was a waitress there for 5 years.

Eric Wild

May 31, 2022

I recently visited the Elias Inn Supper Club for a Friday Fish Fry and was pleasantly surprised to learn the Fish Fry includes Fried Chicken, Fried Cod and Baked Cod served family style with the sides featured on a Lazy Susan. All the food dishes served were very good along with the service. The restaurant does get quite busy on Friday so be prepared for a wait. The Elias Inn Supper Club does unfortunately fall short on the value scale as the only Fish Fry option available is all you can eat. 4.0 (5.0 if you typically order all you can eat).

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do you need reservation for small party?

Mary Janice Powers | Feb 16, 2018
Michele Behm | Feb 17, 2018

Suggested

Read More

Is there outdoor seating available during summer months ?

JoAnne Lovrek | Feb 16, 2018
D Behrens | Feb 17, 2018

No

Read More

Did Elias Inn used to be Otto's Inn?

George Povich | Feb 16, 2020
Kathryn Barbasiewicz | Feb 17, 2020

No. Otto's Inn was on the west end of the same block. Power's Inn was where Elias is.

when will elias inn open under the new owners

beverly koepsell | Jan 18, 2022
Karen Oestreich | Jan 19, 2022

I heard in about a.month. dont know if its true.

What time do you open on Friday

Carol Schroeder | Feb 16, 2020
Charice Finley | Feb 17, 2020

4:00pm

Can you make reservations for a party of 31 on Friday night fish fry?

Jake Roth | Feb 16, 2020
Scott Simpson | Feb 17, 2020

It is a small place, call and ask

Read More

Do you have any weekday specials ?

Charlotte Nelson | Feb 16, 2020
Tom A | Feb 17, 2020

Yes they have different specials on most days.

Read More

Do they serve Sunday Brunch?

Kimberly Corriveau | Feb 16, 2019
Karen Oestreich | Feb 17, 2019

No

Read More

Hi when what applation

Tiffany Reed | Feb 16, 2019
Earl Bednar | Feb 17, 2019

We had an Excellent experience. Last of the Lazy Susan's....

Read More

Is Elias open on Thanksgiving 2017?

Stephanie Halberg | Feb 16, 2018
Karen Oestreich | Feb 17, 2018

No

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places