Widmer's Cheese Cellars

Category: Cheese shop

Address: 214 W Henni St, Theresa, WI 53091, USA

Phone: +18888781107

Opening hours

Sunday: 10AM–3PM

Monday: 7AM–5PM

Tuesday: 7AM–5PM

Wednesday: 7AM–5PM

Thursday: 7AM–5PM

Friday: 7AM–5PM

Saturday: 7AM–5PM

Reviews

William Reed

Jul 7, 2022

Widmer's Cheese Cellars was a fun place to visit on the way to Oshkosh, WI. It is barely off the main highway. Well worth the short trip. When you enter you see where the cheese is made. We watch them making both Cheese Curds and block of Cheddar Cheese. You can see exactly what we saw in the pictures. You can buy all the various cheeses Widmer's Cheese Cellars makes right there when you visit. The prices are VERY reasonable for such a wonderful product.

Christopher Moran

Jul 3, 2022

Fantastic side trip on the way to Door County from Milwaukee. Their brick spread is the best. An awesome tangy alternative to cream cheese.

SUSAN SWENSON

Mar 18, 2022

Best customer service! I ordered for the first time from them and because of a snowstorm FedEx was not able to deliver on time and two of my cheeses were ruined. When I contacted Widmer's, they graciously agreed to send me replacements for free. They also included a brick of sharp cheddar. Great way to keep customers!

Julie Friess

Dec 20, 2021

Cute little store!! Celebrating 100 years this year and stopped to pick up some aged cheeses for the holidays. Great prices and super friendly and welcoming staff!!

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Do they sell Lienderkraz cheese?

carl fromholzer | May 23, 2021
Widmer's Cheese Cellars (Owner) | May 24, 2021

Hello Carl, we sell Aged Brick Cheese which is the closest thing to Liederkranz Cheese that you can get. Our Aged Brick is a German Washed Rind style type of cheese that has a stronger flavor and aroma much like Liederkranz. We also sell Limburger, but we don't make it here. Thanks for the inquiry! Let me know if you have any other questions.

Are the fresh curds ready by 7am on Thursd

Suzanne Luedtke | Jan 18, 2021
Widmer's Cheese Cellars (Owner) | Jan 19, 2021

Fresh cheddar curds will not be ready until 11:15 a.m. on a Thursday. Fresh brick curds are typically Monday-Thursday around 1:15 p.m. Thanks!

Do you have to schedule a tour and tasting or is it a walk in basis?

Jeanne Fenner | Jan 18, 2021
Paige McEathron | Jan 19, 2021

Looks like they aren't doing tours but you can watch them make the cheese during certain hours. Here's the link for more info from their website. https://www.widmerscheese.com/retail-store/

Read More

Do they offer fresh cheese curds on Fridays????

Suzanne Luedtke | Jan 18, 2021
William Lukomski | Jan 19, 2021

I believe they have fresh curds available everyday

Read More

Are there cheese curds Squeaky fresh

Chris Lamont | Jan 19, 2020
Widmer's Cheese Cellars (Owner) | Jan 20, 2020

Hello Chris it varies from day to day! The brick curds are normally fresh on Monday-Thursday. The original cheddar curds are normally made on Thursday's. Once, the curds are under refrigeration they lose their squeakiness. The one way the get that squeakiness back is by placing them in the microwave for no longer than 20 seconds.

Do you have tours of your cheese making area

Darlene Koeppel | Jan 19, 2020
Widmer's Cheese Cellars (Owner) | Jan 20, 2020

We are unable to give tours thru our facility due to government food safety regulations. However, if come to our retail store you will be able to see the cheese making facility. The best time to come is between 7am-10:30am Monday-Friday to view the cheese making in action.

Read More

do you make chocolate cheese?

Sandra Polencheck | Jan 19, 2020
Widmer's Cheese Cellars (Owner) | Jan 20, 2020

We do not make or sell chocolate cheese from our retail store. Thanks!

Read More

Is there a connection between this place and the brewery of the same name?

Jeffrey Hotson | Jan 19, 2020
Widmer's Cheese Cellars (Owner) | Jan 20, 2020

Hello Jeffrey, we have heard of them, but there is no connection! Thanks!

Read More

Just tried you brick spread...outstanding what other spreads do you offer and where in greenbay area?.

Bill Feucht | Jan 19, 2019
Jim Freiberg | Jan 20, 2019

I don 'work there but I have tried their other spreads. All are great they are located in Thersa just off Hwy 41 @ the Hwy 28 exit in Dodge County

Read More

What day would I be able to get the freshest cheese curds?

Aaron Miller | Jan 19, 2019
Jim Freiberg | Jan 20, 2019

Call them

Read More

How long is sealed cheese good for? We just got our box and the dates on the cheese are 10/16!! Some of the cheese has mold on it?

swirly sommer | Jan 19, 2018
Robert Schellin | Jan 20, 2018

And it really depends on the cheese some will mold sooner than others but the mold really won't hurt just cut it off and the rest of the cheese will be fine. It is best to use cheese up sooner than later because it does deteriorate over time. Crazy and cheese will help make it last longer. When was the cheese purchased that would be my next question as far as how old the cheese was that you got and who purchased for you if you did not did they have it sitting around for awhile and for how long was it unrefrigerated?

I am ordering a Christmas gift box. How long from ordering to shipping to Florida?

Suzanne Costa | Jan 19, 2018
Lynn | Jan 20, 2018

Oh goodness, Suzanne, I just shop there. You'd have to give them a call. I'm sure if you order within the next few days, it would be priority shipping because of the fact that it's perishable. Wish I could have helped. Make sure you order some Colby!

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places