Amenia Steakhouse

R and C Numismatics

I want to start by saying the waitress we had and the bartender were amazing. Super friendly, good drinks and they genuinely tried their best. However, that is all this place has going for it. The food is overpriced and it is really poor quality. The steak I wanted in my food (the steak in my girlfriend’s food and the burger my stepdad had) was to be medium rare and every single one had medium well cooked meats. Do not pride yourself on being a steakhouse if you can’t cook meats. The food took two hours to be done for our group of 6 people. Some groups even left because it was taking too long. As if that wasn’t bad enough, the owner was there drunk (at 6:45 pm) and was screaming at employees to clean tables and plates, talking about firing certain people, swearing at employees and even threatening to fire all employees. His attitude made this establishment a one star. I would not recommend it as he is apparently always there and rude to employees after 4pm when he gets drunk.

Josette T

Cool and casual place to get a bite to eat. Great staff and management. Very friendly. We had calamari app - average. Loaded potato skins with pulled chicken was very tasty. Salmon served with mashed potatoes and some steamed veggies. Nothing memorable. Osso bucco not authentic and in more of a sweet sauce rather then a rich savory sauce. Filet mignon cooked perfectly but plain. Two apps, four dinners, four tap beers and one soda, no dessert or coffee was $189. I would definitely stop back for lunch but not for dinner. Their lunch menu looks great and is reasonably priced. I will be back to try lunch. Food unfortunately seems to be more of a restaurant supplier quality. I may be wrong though. I’m just basing it on what we had. Give it a try. Good location.

David McDonald

Ironically, We visited on Saint Patrick's day, was welcomed by the owner after he noticed the staff was busy to seat us, accommodated drink order, checked in to make sure we had a pleasant experience a few times during the dinner service, Stake special was actually well executed and had a vary flavorful but not overwhelming spice,, will come back to try the other stake specials with friends soon

Felix Meshman

Fabulous !!! My wife and I visited Wing’s Castle. After our delightful tour we grabbed a bite to eat at this place. The food was out of this world. My steak and her crab legs were to die for !!! The waiter/manager was courteous and super friendly. He was also resourceful and gave us tips on wineries to visit.