Ship Lantern Inn

Category: American restaurant

Address: 1725 Rte 9W, Milton, NY 12547, USA

Phone: +18457955400

Opening hours

Sunday: 1–8PM

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 4–9:30PM

Wednesday: 4–9:30PM

Thursday: 4–9:30PM

Friday: 4–9:30PM

Saturday: 1–10PM

Reviews

Gerald Albertie

Jul 25, 2022

It is a little dicey for a disabled to navigate from the parking area to the dining area. However, that said one word covers the staff and the food EXCELLENT. We go there as our special event restaurant, it is about 40 mile ride from home.

S H

Apr 26, 2022

Pros: Place was well kept and clean. Dining room staff provided good service. Cons: Overuse of salt to make up for the all too subtle flavor of the ingredients. Price was high for what was served. Consideration: There is a formal vibe and the clientel is predominantly older people.

Mike Rivera

Feb 13, 2022

I took food to go. I ordered French onion soup which I switched to a crock and reheated, needed salt for my taste but was fine after adding about a teaspoon. Steak is fine. It was cooked properly. Tuna dish was greatly lacking, had tons of silver skin and was oxidized beyond what I’d expect from food that traveled a short distance. Butternut squash Risotto was cooked rice with heavy cream and a few large sixes of butternut squash. Incredibly disappointing and seemingly lazy execution. I assume the good reviews have to do with service and dining experience because the food framed alone is greatly lacking

Janice K

Dec 22, 2021

We had a great time at Ship Lantern Inn - the food was solid, the wine and beverages list was great (and surprisingly varied with good selections) and the staff and atmosphere were excellent. Would definite revisit next time we are in the area!

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

What style cuisine is this; and is it upscale or casual? Finally, would you rate it $,$$,$$$,$$$$ or $$$$$?

Joseph G | Feb 5, 2019
Butch Dener | Feb 6, 2019

A Classic Room with an old school ambiance and Staff. Eclectic Menu with so many good selections you need a table of 6 to order everything you want to taste 😊

Read More

what days open and times?

Mary Brennie | Aug 8, 2020
Patrice Rosa | Aug 9, 2020

As Long Time Patron I do know they are Closed on Monday's

Read More

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

People are asking | Feb 17, 2021
Mary Ellen Farrier | Feb 18, 2021

Social distancing is practiced. Food is still amazing and so is the staff.

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places