Insomnia Cookies

Category: Cookie shop in Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Address: 1804 E North Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53202, USA

Phone: +14142401647

Opening hours

Sunday: 12PM–12AM

Monday: 11AM–12AM

Tuesday: 11AM–12AM

Wednesday: 11AM–12AM

Thursday: 11AM–1AM

Friday: 11AM–1AM

Saturday: 12PM–1AM

Reviews

Sarah

Jul 21, 2022

I had never been to Insomnia Cookies and was very excited to try it, however I did not get to due to the very poor customer service. We walked in and the one employee there was standing by the register on her cell phone, with it on speaker, clearly on a personal phone call. She did not acknowledge us at all and continued to talk on the phone while we stood by the register ready to order. She then turned around and walked into the back, again still on her phone. We waited for her to come back but she did not and we decided to leave as we did not even want to give them our business at that point. Very disappointed.

Keith Wisniewski

May 31, 2022

Waited 30 minutes, found out at second in line they were out of half the cookies we wanted to get. Grabbed a six pack of cookies and a pint of milk. Cookies are the size of Subway's, milk was 20 days past the sell by date, and waiting in line for half an hour was in no way worth it. Two stars because the cookies were good, but just grab the $5 box from pick n' save. No way were six worth fifteen bucks.

Faviola Morales

Mar 28, 2022

Best cookies ever! I got the vegan 6 pack of birthday, chocolate chunk and double chocolate (2 of each). It was 12.95 for the 6 pack, making it a treat yo self kind of splurge, but honestly it is totally worth it!! They are warm, gooey and delicious!!! Service was friendly and fast and the cookies were amazing so I will definitely be coming back!

Victoria Frederichs

Feb 14, 2022

Great cookies, but delivered at the incorrect time. I made an order for delivery from 4-6 pm and they arrived just after 3; naturally we had to pull strings to get someone to pick them up since there was no drop off available in our building. We verified that the receipt DID say 4-6pm; they were sent out early regardless. People choose specific times for a reason; it was really stressful for us and the delivery driver to make the drop off work…

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Can we stop and hangout in the shop for a bit? Or is it strickly in and out for cookies?

Sophia Manske | Dec 17, 2019
Hunter Stoehr (lifeofmusic468) | Dec 18, 2019

They never seem to mind a bit of company

Read More

Do you accept cash or do you have to pay with credit card?

Jasmine Story | Dec 16, 2020
Juanita Washington | Dec 17, 2020

No cash only credit

Dairy free options?

Drake Strand | Jun 19, 2021
TinaRoxx | Jun 20, 2021

We do carry vegan and vegan gluten free options.

How far is their delivery area?

Carla “Lala” Salter | Dec 9, 2021
McKenzie Carlson | Dec 10, 2021

They say that they do but I ordered online and never received the order as they canceled it after 3 hours of waiting.

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places