Thirsty Pony Restaurant

Category: American restaurant in Sandusky, Ohio

Address: 1935 Cleveland Rd W, Sandusky, OH 44870, USA

Phone: +14196266761

Opening hours

Sunday: 11AM–10PM

Monday: 11AM–10PM

Tuesday: 11AM–10PM

Wednesday: 11AM–10PM

Thursday: 11AM–10PM

Friday: 11AM–10PM

Saturday: 11AM–10PM

Reviews

MrKcg252

Jul 17, 2022

Restaurant is very dirty ,floors ,bathroom it even smells .silverware was dirty so I asked for to-go utensils. To be very honest once you get over the unclean part and the smell the food is actually really good 👍 I'm thinking because its a popular bar is why it is so ran down the staff is friendly and food was good I can't lie

Tara

Apr 21, 2022

I had high hopes for the Thirsty Pony, but unfortunately the food missed the mark for the most part. This rating is solely based on our food experience. Food is in the photos. Here is what my family of 4 had: - cheese stick stack appetizer (good) - southwest egg roll appetizer (good) - sauerkraut balls appetizer (it was like a Reuben ball with sausage in it instead of corned beef. It was just alright) - Buffalo chicken dip (didn’t care for this. Was too sweet and tasted weird) - I had the mango jalapeño wings. (These were delicious but quite spicy. Definitely made me tear up a little) - lobster bisque in a bread bowl (this was my least favorite thing out of the whole meal. It was this fake orange color and just did not taste good.) - my husband and stepsons all had different burgers and none of them cared for them I do like the feel of the bar and I’m sure it is a great place to go to drink, bet on horse races through their simulcast area, and/or play lottery. Unfortunately, due to an upcoming surgery, I was not able to try any of their many signature cocktails. There is also bowling and axe throwing at this location.

cory randall

Mar 19, 2022

So this is a great bar that kinda serves as a restaurant. It's also connected to a bowling alley and other fun stuff to do. it's definitely not fine dining but mid class bar food I'd have to say they do alot of it to order tho. It's a bit cluttered with advertising but I guess that catches your eye to find stuff. I like the everyday specials and they have low prices. I recommend the pretzel and I didn't have it but my brother recommend the wings. He also loved the cinnamon butter lol. The service we got was very good. I would recommend this place. I would also recommend the onion rings!! This bar is very generous when it comes to shots and pours very worth your money.i recommend the sweet potato waffle fry's.

David Glenn

Jan 20, 2022

Just WOW! Took a risk and ate here at the referral of a co-worker. They had mid day specials on most of the appetizers, burgers and pizzas. I was blown away! Everything was good! I ended up getting onion rings, fried pickles, and a pizza. WAY TOO MUCH FOOD FOR OND PERSON!!! My bill? $19.75. The pickles are out of sight! The special house sauce will catch you off guard. A bit of a sweetness at the beginning, then it kicks you about 5 seconds in. I tried one of my friend’s sliders. Also tried the pretzel. Equally as good. Sorry, the pizza ended up going in a to-go box for later. Please note that the food pics don’t do justice! We had eaten half of the onion rings and pickles before I remembered to take pics. Oh, and they have a full sized bowling alley, axe throwing, a gambling room…

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Are there fountain drinks?

Dylan Thomas Salada | Dec 14, 2018
william baker | Dec 15, 2018

Yes n a bar

Read More

im new to Sandusky moved here from florida is this spot good to meet locals ?

minimangas18 | Dec 14, 2018
Monica Gregory | Dec 15, 2018

I am a local, we are there bowling or eating most days of the week. Great staff, great food, good specials during the off season and much to do in the complex. Check it out definitely

Read More

Do you have hot dogs as a choice for kids?

SteeZ | Dec 14, 2018
Bill Griffin | Dec 15, 2018

They have a great kids menu.

Read More

Are you required to wear a mask to eat here?????

Nicole Anne | Dec 13, 2020
Miles Johnson | Dec 14, 2020

Yes, but while you eat or drink you may have it off.

Can you sit at the bar with COVID rules.

Rob Sharp | Dec 13, 2020
Wesley Cavinder | Dec 14, 2020

Yeah I went there and saw people sitting there at the bar

Read More

Can I watch ufc tonight?

Damian Mańko | Dec 14, 2019
Michael Kirksey | Dec 15, 2019

Don't know if they have pay for view.

Is there Gluten Free options

Graham Craig | Dec 14, 2018
Harold Person | Dec 15, 2018

Food is good

Read More

When does Xmas Ale come out in July?!

Eric Lujano | Dec 14, 2018
Ronald Latosinski | Dec 15, 2018

Thats a good question myself i am not sure. But a phone call to them should give you your answer.

Are they opening today. July 4

Mr Willis | Dec 14, 2018
Derek Sheridan | Dec 15, 2018

I hope you didn't wait on us to answer before going. Did you call? Are you there?

Read More

Do they have slot machines

Mr Willis | Dec 14, 2018
Stacey Crosby | Dec 15, 2018

No, but other fun stuff!

Read More

When is burger night?

Glenn Klein | Dec 14, 2018
Derek Sheridan | Dec 15, 2018

Didn't know it was ever a thing. I wonder what Father's Day at the Thirsty Pony will be like. Perhaps they'll have something for you, then.

Read More

Do u have blackhause

Veronica Tittle | Dec 14, 2019
Monica Gregory | Dec 15, 2019

Yes

Do they still have the golf simulator

Kevin Jessee | Dec 14, 2018
Michael Waddle | Dec 15, 2018

Yes they have the golf simulator

Read More

When do they stop serving food??

Justin Walker | Dec 14, 2018
Darrick Hawkins | Dec 15, 2018

To 12midnight.

How much is a night

Tina Young | Dec 14, 2017
Tiffany Thomas | Dec 15, 2017

On expedia it was $109

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places