The Bagelry

Amy Ketterling

Very yummy bagels! Simple menu that offers exactly what you want in a bagel or bagel sandwich. Friendly staff! Highly recommend.

Matthew Welter

Super good bagel shop. Definitely worth a stop if you’re going through evergreen, imo worth a stop no matter what. Great atmosphere, comfy places to sit indoor and outdoor and board games too!!

Neel Parekh

Can i make this 6 stars? Those bagels were possibly the best I’ve ever had. The guys there are also incredibly nice. I have decided to make it a point to stop by every time I’m in the area. Cheers!

Mel Lo

I can't remember a time when my family didn't get bagels at The Bagelry after getting morning groceries. They are classic bagels - none of the steaming nonsense that you get at Einstein's. These are big, chewy, boiled bagels. They taste great and have great texture. My favorite is the mountain power bagel followed closely by the classic poppyseed. My dad prefers jalapeño cheddar. My mom likes their sesame and also the cranberry walnut. Really, these are some of the best bagels in Colorado and have been consistently good for more than 20 years. I'm speaking as someone who's had bagels in NYC, Boston, CT and Rhode Island. These are damn good bagels.