Mystic Ice Cream Cafe

Category: Ice cream shop

Address: Route #466A, 1217 W Miller St, Fruitland Park, FL 34731, USA

Phone: +13528121366

Opening hours

Sunday: 1–9PM

Monday: 1–9PM

Tuesday: 1–9PM

Wednesday: 1–9PM

Thursday: 1–9PM

Friday: 1–9PM

Saturday: 1–9PM

Reviews

Darice Voigt

Jul 2, 2022

Prepare yourself for an experience with this place! The inside is decorated with rock and TV show memorabilia all over the room. The tables are eclectic and vibrantly colored so you feel like you are in flower child heaven. Oh and the ice cream? Well, that is to die for! We had the adult ice cream and both flavors were amazing! We can't wait to go back in the evening for all of their fun things like karaoke and trivia.

Rebecca Kenefick

Jan 20, 2022

Great place! Workers are nice, and ice cream is delicious. Wide variety of flavors, and even some flavors with alcohol in them for adults. Decorations are cute and the whole place has a nice hippie vibe

Beard Adventures (Beard Adventures)

Dec 6, 2021

This place is really cool. Has a really fun vibe. There are so many cool things to look at. 32 homemade flavors 16 with 21+ adult flavors and 16 without also looks like they have some seasonal flavors. Make sure to get the punch card when you get your ice cream. A new location in Leesburg.

J V

Jul 18, 2021

This ice cream is so freaking amazing. Well worth the drive from Orlando. The banana pudding shake was creamy and just perfect. The coconut rum ice cream, yes, it has real alcohol, was delicious. The bailey's ice cream, again, with alcohol, was very tasty, and the cappuccino chip ice cream has coffee ice cream with chocolate covered coffee beans and chocolate chips. Joey V. says "Check it out !"

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

What time do they start the name that tune game on Wed nights?

Bob Orkis | Sep 8, 2020
jeanne lomax | Sep 8, 2020

Would get there early to get a table/seat.

Read More

Is mystic ice cream still open? Their phone number is disconnected.

Donna Twiss | Sep 8, 2020
Denny Lawson | Sep 8, 2020

Also in the midst of ownership change.

Read More

How late are they open?

Poletta Guffey | Sep 9, 2018
Ed Borchers | Sep 8, 2021

9 PM

Read More

Am I allowed to sit outside/inside with my dog? Ty

mathew mathew | Jun 10, 2022
Angela Acrey | Jun 10, 2022

I know for sure outside is fine, not sure about inside.

What are the Covid safety practices like here?

Anonymous | Sep 8, 2022
Kim Brightman | Sep 8, 2021

Masks required upon entry and while ordering.

Read More

Do they have snow cones/shaved ice?

Regan Zink | Sep 8, 2020
Rebekah Phillips | Sep 8, 2020

No they have original ice cream flavors...even some adult only flavors...with a congruently unique decor and the friendliest hometown service combining to make an experience to remember and one to which you desire to return.

Do you have to be 21 to get the alcohol infused flavors?

Breanna Harner | Sep 8, 2020
Nan | Sep 8, 2020

Yep. They have lots of options for minors.

Read More

What time do you close on tuesdats

Janet Reinecke | Sep 9, 2019
Molly Katherine | Sep 9, 2019

10 PM.

Read More

M

Anonymous | Sep 8, 2022
Anonymous | Sep 8, 2022

y

what activities are there nightly??

Arlene _ | Sep 9, 2019
Meredith Kramer | Sep 9, 2019

Every night is different. One night is trivia, another karaoke, another there's a DJ. Try their website...and the ice cream! Come hungry since the portions are HUGE

Read More

is there music every night?

patricia gilbert | Sep 9, 2019
Robert Stultz | Sep 9, 2019

Never been there

Is every Wednesday night Name That Tune night? If so, what time does it start, and are reservations needed?

Nancy Stryker | Sep 9, 2018
Deb Eberle | Sep 9, 2018

They don't take reservations We took a group of 12 people & were treated poorly so won't be going back.

Read More

Is mystic open now? We went last night and they were closed...

Kathie | Sep 9, 2018
D J | Sep 9, 2018

Call first. They may have been closed for Hurricane Irma.

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places