Sutter's Mill Restaurant

Ana D'Amico

Just simple and delicious. Love the old vibes style. Generous portions and great service. I love living so close by to this un assuming gem of a restaurant

Kimberly Stowe

They're doing a great job on limited resources. The salmon was pretty good, the shrimp cocktail was tasty and the service was excellent. I've also had very nice steaks here in the past. It's a nice little local place that is obviously loved by the people in Simi...judging by how busy it was on Wednesday night.

Carol Heise

Found this on a Google search looking for a reasonably priced meal with a steak in Simi Valley. Turned out to be a great surprise. People there were very personable from customers while waiting for our table to the one of the best waiters ever. Food was generous and cooked correctly. Very busy place, but it didn't effect service. Loved the tribute table to the fallen military as you enter restaurant. All food was good considering the reasonable prices. We would definitely visit this place again.

Brenda

My husband and I, actually really enjoyed our dinner and experience here but I will explain why I wasn't able to give this establishment 5 stars. The prices were a little too steep for their food quality. Don't misunderstand me. The food was delicious but by no means anywhere near a Fleming's Steakhouse quality. You could pay a little bit more and go to Fleming's. On the other hand, you may just want to stay close to home or might not be able to get to a Fleming's or a steakhouse as good as a Fleming's. In that case, I would recommend to give this place a try. Another little issue we had, was that we ordered our prime rib to be cooked medium rare and they brought it to us, medium. We didn't bother sending it back because it was still flavored very well, just not as juicy as we like. The creamy horseradish was more like, barely flavored sour cream, but my husband liked it that way. We also ordered the stuffed mushrooms, for an appetizer, and those were just "ok". They do have a delicious deep fried cheese cake, and that came with coffee. The decor is very cozy and made for a great ambience! Our bill, before tip, was $112.00. This included; 2- ice teas, 1- 12oz. prime rib dinner, 1- 16oz. prime rib dinner, 1- appetizer and 1- dessert. If you decide to give this place a try, I hope you have a great experience!