Rustic Tavern

Category: Steak house in Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Address: 823 Newville Rd, Carlisle, PA 17013, USA

Phone: +17172452999

Opening hours

Sunday: Closed

Monday: 11AM–10PM

Tuesday: 11AM–10PM

Wednesday: 11AM–10PM

Thursday: 11AM–10PM

Friday: 11AM–10PM

Saturday: 11AM–10PM

Reviews

Joleen Gordon

Apr 2, 2022

The kids spaghetti is sour an the adult ribs are rubber, onion rings okay so you get 1 star for them because the shrimp an scallop kabob Way over spiced "heart burn" an chicken Alfredo - there was no Chicken an it's bland , hard briskets bad bar drinks All sour mash Not top shelf. Definitely a dive. The waitress couldn't even give a recommendation for what to actually try ,my guess because it was All 😞 Bad an Sad food.

Todd Buonadonna

Mar 26, 2022

Was in town for a sporting event with the family. We ordered takeout here and it was very good! We ordered prime rib and stuffed shrimp with crab meat but the best was their seafood in red sauce over garlic bread! And I think the prices are absolutely awesome as well! We were very happy!

Raymond Grimes

Jan 30, 2022

Absolutely Amazing! Traveling from out of town with a family of 5. Everyone was extremely impressed with their meals, cocktails, and service. I had the french onion soup, stuffed shrimp and scallops. Everything was perfect. Amanda our server was wonderful. I highly recommend this local restaurant. Skip the chains and eat & support local!

Jacob Hoover

Sep 17, 2021

Had the fish and chips. The fish taste good but was overcooked and had to eat it with a fork. Awesome zesty coleslaw. The sweet potato fries were good.

Thanks! Your review is awaiting moderation.

Questions & Answers

Can you call and order than pick up

Rita Bruckner | Aug 9, 2019
José Nuñez | Aug 10, 2019

Yes, you absolutely can. In fact, I would recommend that.

Read More

Can you order from lunch and dinner menu during dinner time?

Erika Wilkins | Aug 9, 2019
Duane Alleman | Aug 10, 2019

Yes

Read More

Do you need reservations

Darin Long | Aug 8, 2020
Brendan McCaffrey | Aug 9, 2020

advise reservations ! busy busy place 😃 but they always do their best to slot in strays.

Read More

Do you serve beer & wine??

Donald Michaels | Aug 9, 2019
Bill Landefeld | Aug 10, 2019

Yes, excellent selection and great food.

Read More

Hello, Do you offer a senior discount?

Vicki Fry | Aug 9, 2018
Donna E Keske | Aug 10, 2018

You need to ask

Read More

What time do you start saving dinner?

Sharon Sheaffer | Aug 9, 2018
Stephen Letsky | Aug 10, 2018

I believe around 4 pm

Read More

Thanks! Your answer is awaiting moderation.

Thanks! Your question is awaiting moderation.

Related Places