Antonio's Real New York Pizza

Kevin Labadessa

The best eatery in Estes. The pizza is East Coast style- which is the best pizza of course. The sauce was very flavorful, and I loved the hints of fresh basil. If you get grandma pizza tell them well done so you don’t get a soggy crust. Fellow travelers I highly recommend Antonio’s.

Sarah

The BEST tasting pizza ever. Hands down. WOW. Standing in line at the hikers shuttle and asked the attendant checking passes, what was the best pizza in town. Antonio's down the road he told me. It didn't disappoint. There was about a 30 min wait, put your name on the list at the front when you get there. The crust was thin but didn't turn soggy. Just enough greasy. Soooooo good. This was 26" and an order of cheese garlic bread and order of regular garlic bread. Walking distance from a lot of hotels. Can accommodate larger families. Highly recommend.

Rob Hatch

So, I'm going to start with three fact that the NY style pizza here is some of the best I've ever had. Period. Beautiful combination of light crispy chewy crust with flavorful San Marzano tomato sauce. I got the Italian sausage, but I imagine any of the toppings are fantastic. 10/10 pizza, and it was worth the hour and a half drive from Lakewood too visit Estes Park for that alone. Antonio, well done! My wife came with me and we were bummed to find out that there isn't much available to deal with gluten allergies, but it's a pizza place so we get it. That being said, we ordered some wings for her to eat and they appear to bake them in the pizza oven which results in some great color and good crunch without the fat from deep frying so that was nice. That being said, you guys *HAVE* to up your sauce game. We ordered some standard buffalo wings and some with Carolina BBQ sauce and they brought out the wings on plates cooked, but the sauce came on the side in little dishes. Both sauces were cold and it appeared as though they had just poured them out of their respective bottles into the dishes. For the BBQ, not the end of the world, but I'm sorry, you've gotta have butter mixed with your Frank's sauce on wings. You just have to. Also disappointing was the wings did not come with celery or blue cheese. It wasn't described on the menu to their credit, bit it would make it better. The staff seemed to walk on a rotation through the dining room and were very friendly and helpful. The food took about 15-20 minutes to come out to us after we had ordered. The walls were decorated with various pictures/street signs calling out New York neighborhoods and the booths were decorated with NYC taxis. There was some music playing quietly in the background, but it was drowned out by the conversation of the packed dining room. The bathrooms were clean and well stocked. Last thing I noticed as we were leaving, people were waiting at the front door for seating, so plan ahead because you might have a wait to get pizza this good. Good news is you can order takeout! Go here! It's bomb pizza. I took off a star for the wing sauce, but I'll be back to try their Sicilian style and some of their other entrees. Keep up the good work guys!

Amanda

This was my first visit to Antonio's and I will definitely return when in town! I decided to use online ordering for a to-go order and found it very easy to use. Prices were clear, customization was simple (with many options) and out of stock items were marked as such. The order was ready early which is always a plus! The staff was friendly and efficient with the pick up process. And most importantly, the pizza, cheesecake and cider were absolutely delicious! 🍕