Caterina's Ristorante

Karen

A perfect place to enjoy an Italian dinner. Great staff, extensive menu of well prepared Italian food. I enjoyed every last slurp of linguini with clams. The salad, bread, and appetizer platter are also very satisfying before the meal arrives.

Leia Lee Olivarez

This is probably the best Italian restaurant I have ever eaten at. The lasagna was delicious and I highly recommend it. Also, get the carrot cake because it is so moist and the frosting is so good even though I’m not frosting person. Service was great and the lady who served us was lovely and sweet. Overall, the service and all of our food of a family of five was delicious and we will definitely be back!

Kady Gibowski

My favorite hidden gem for sure. Tonight was my second experience and it was so memorable. The best part of this place, aside from the food and lovely atmosphere, is Trudy. She is such a gem. Her recommendations are always the best-especially her salad dressing. She is a true professional. If you want really wonderful authentic Italian food and wine and extraordinary service, this is the jam. We are big fans. Keep it up, Caterina's!

Karen Altergott Roberts

Love this place! Setting from a time past, good and abundant bread, a small but delicious appetizer, and ample, delicious main courses and sides, Caterina’s was a lovely, leisurely and filling place to dine. No rushing. Thoughtful service, with each person acting as if they were part owner! From the hostess to the waitress, to the person who cleared the table and prepared our take-home container, everyone was special. There are nice booths, but I imagine they fill quickly, and the area near the window was pleasant as well! A delightful Wisconsin feast.