Pizzeria Scotty

Justin Provance

Finally tried this locally owned pizza place a friend recommend and am glad I did. Everything looked good and the most delicious smells filled the place. We ultimately couldn't decide so ended up getting a double dough and a stuffed pizza. The food was amazing and so were the leftovers! My opinion is this place beats the big chains in taste and price!

randy mcphail

Ordered from Pizzaria Scotty for the first time since moving out this way and all I can say is that I was not overwhelmed. The overall quality was good, amount of topping was fine, crust was good, the price was competitive. BUT the sauce may as well not have even been there. I grew up eating pizza from some of the most iconic pizza places in Milwaukee, and surrounding areas, and one thing they generally have in common is the tang of a good sauce. Sadly that was not there in the pizza I ordered from here. It may be great for some but I will continue to search for a pizza place in this area that serves up a classic, old school Milwaukee style pizza that hits on all cylinders.

Jamie Wojczak

Hello!! Not only is this my FAVORITE PIZZA PLACE!! Best Pizza in Townnnn by far!!! But they also treat customers with the up most respect:) When I attempted calling and ordering online yesterday evening to pick up dinner after my work shift, the system seemed to be down. So working under Customer Service myself, I completely understood that Technology can treat us hot or cold sometimes;)…. Well, I was CRAVING their pizza so bad… I walked in person to order:) The debit machine was not picking up my card, so the Cashier who was assisting me, went to his phone to transact the transaction with a Square Card Method, This was the last option in paying for my order, and he did not want me to leave disappointed after my many attempts to order! Well, he did just that and completed my order!!! I was sooo excited and happy that he went through hoops during their busy, dinner time to make this dinner happen!!! On top of his kindness, his ambition to make the whole Pizza Place smile was beyond amazing!! I love everyones energy in there! They really mark their Business with a Gold Star!! Impressive:) The quality of the Pizza is exceptional and leftovers for lunch are even better:) Keep Being Amazing!!!

Jake Chybowski

Pizza was wrong (it was suppose to be half shrooms instead of full shrooms) never got a conformation email or anything and to top it all off it didnt even look good i won't lie this is pathetic and i worked in pizza for 4 years now. Like the food was not worth the 90 minute wait