Main Street Pizza of Tarrytown

dan

I ordered Penne with olive oil and garlic sauce. The pasta was cooked very well in Al dente, but the meatball was too dry and taste was plain. I thing this dish needed more salt and more sauce.

Magda Maisonet

So an “estimated delivery time of 5:15-5:25” means possibly more than 30 minutes later? I have ordered from this place a few times and they have been on the money when it comes to their ‘estimated delivery time’. But when they’re not, it’s a guessing game. The food is good for a pizza shop. I dreaded when I saw the place was sold, but it seems to be about as good as the former owners. And I appreciated the free delivery. But what is the point of free delivery - and pre-tipping - when they can’t deliver as promised? I am now over 30 minutes wait time on a delivery with 3 hangry people. Please end our misery. REVISING review due to unforeseen circumstances (delivery driver had a flat). My only ask is that should this occur again, a courtesy call to the customer advising of the delay would go a long way. Instead I was told "It's on the way" which turned into an hour later (2 hrs total from time ordered for ASAP delivery).

Jordanna Jayy

I've ordered from thisplace about 3 times and their pizza is great every time! The store is clean and most of the staff are pretty friendly. Their buffalo slice is amazing! I'm a big chocolate chip cookie fan, but I found their cookies to be just okay. Other than that, this is one of my fav pizzerias in Tarrytown! *excuse my bitten slice, I had to sample it first ;)

Dungeon Master

Edit: I went back and safe to say will never return. What they pass for pizza looks like it came out of an easy bake oven. Small, flat and to my eyes, unappealing. *************************************** What was once a great place for pizza (under the previous owners) sadly no longer exist. The new owners took the time to renovate the place but seem to have forgotten to hang up the menu and prices. So it's anyone's guess as to what you're paying for the items available. As for the pizza I did see, they reminded me of those pizza places in Manhattan where they charge a dollar. The cheese Sicilian looked nice though. In regards to ordering a pie half cheese, half sausage, well, the picture I added shows sparingly placed crumbled sausage bits. Whereas other pizza places use lengthwise or circular slices, this is pathetic and the price is far more than it's worth.