Keeler’s Neighborhood Steakhouse

Elise Cousineau

I should have ordered the burger! I ordered the beef brisket sandwich on the Happy Hour Menu. I asked the BBQ sauce be served on the side. I got BBQ sauce on the side, but it was also on the sandwich. I could have sent it back, but I didn't. The beef brisket was way too fatty for my taste. The other folks order Hamburgers and were very happy. The fries and onion rings are tasty.

Ron Roche

Visited with a group of work colleagues and had a great meal on their outdoor patio. The patio is equipped with misters which kept us all quite comfortable. The food and service were top notch. I had the filet with grilled asparagus and mashed potatoes. Cooked to perfection!

Stephen Harris

Dinner at Keeler's recently. Lovely atmosphere. The wait staff were friendly and professional. Nice level of energy yet not noisy. I ordered the 8oz filet which was pricy. $50. So I had high expectations. I ordered it Medium. It came well done. The wait staff was apologetic but my party had all been served and I wanted to dine with them. They need to get it right for that price.

Zan Lee

I would say it’s one of my favorite restaurants in the Carefree/Cave Creek area. It’s a really consistent, casual, American Contemporary cuisine with tons of indoor, outdoor, and even rooftop seating (a really nice option in the Spring or late Fall). Tonight we chose to sit outdoors and being December 26th it was very cold outside but the heaters felt nice and made it quite warm. Our server was very polite and attentive and management checked in on us mid meal as well. Parking is plentiful and they also have a large bar right behind the hostess stand. I started the meal with the French Onion Soup and it was actually really tasty. Prepared classic style with a deep brown broth (my preference instead of the white colored style) and plenty of Gruyère melted on top. For my entree I chose the 12oz Filet Mignon which had a nice char to it as well as a nice taste. I would definitely order it again I finished every bite. Finally for dessert I topped off the meal with a few scoops of strawberry and caramel gelato. An all around great meal! I would suggest to anyone for almost any occasion. It is a casual setting so may not be right for certain formal meals but for a nice dinner it would be a great choice any night.