Sal and Carmine Pizza

Kermit TMF / SKINNY PENGUS

Overpriced pizza, $5 per pepperoni pizza slice. Not worth it. Definitely for tourists so they can say “it’s New York” Pizza was not even all that. Dominoes and Papa johns is better. 7/10 pizza. Not worth it.

Todd Paquette

Visited Sal & Carmine's Pizza two days ago. Pizza variety selection is excellent. Smells great. Sat in the back and chilled with my kids and a bud. Not too expensive...perfectly suitable for an NYC street slice of pizza.

Henry Chung

Great traditional NYC pizza! Had it 6 years ago on a previous trip so when we planned on coming back to NYC, this was a must stop location for local pizza. Quieter neighborhood as well. Limited seating FYI

Melody Hagaman

My husband and I went here in 2016. I stupidly thought I would remember the place name to recommend to friends. I forgot (in my defense we tried a lot of pizza places some great and some not so much). This one was spectacular. Like magic on a slice. So every few months I have been looking up pizza places in New York/Manhattan to try to find this one. It was that good. I finally found it! If we ever get back to Manhattan we will 100% go again.