Premier Diner Commack

Nate Khan

Relatively dissatisfied and disappointed. First off my waitress was absolutely fantastic, she was very attentive, quick and helpful. This is my second visit to this establishment. My first was before the renovation. My first visit about 7 months ago was absolutely fantastic. This visit was sketchy for a number of reasons. I believe the owner was the one seating people on my most recent visit. He was watching the tables and wait staff like a hawk the entire time I ate. It was unsettling. I’m assuming a big part of this is because the tips seem to go to the house and not the waitress’s and waiter’s which I find terrible. I really wanted to like this place, I travel for work so every 3-4 months I stay at the Hilton behind the restaurant which makes it convenient to walk to. The Vodka on the rocks that I was served had to be about 90% water unlike the first time I dined. I probably won’t be back and I REALLY hope the support staff here is being paid what they’re worth, though I doubt it. TLDR; Waitress and support staff are great, food is meh, house tips are shameful, drinks are weak.

J. P.

It was my first visit to this establishment and upon entering I was greeted and sat immediately, service was good, food was decent though could of used some more seasoning. Alittle pricey but understandable during the times we are facing.

Lisa C

This rating is not because the food isn't good or the service is bad. I live close by, and have been eating in this diner since they opened. We ordered out from here throughout the whole pandemic supporting them every week when it was very quiet. In recent months, their prices have skyrocketed. I went there for lunch today. Had a tuna salad sandwich and orange juice. You will see the bill is close to $22.00. I think that's outrageous. Diners beware of their incredibly high prices.

Jeffrey Lewis

After seeing a comedy show we needed something to eat . And at 10:30pm why not breakfast at a diner. At first glance of the menu I noticed above average prices. After I got my food, I was happy to pay the prices. Food was delicious!!