Castaways Seafood and Grille

Chris Tremblay

LAME! Went with a party of 5 and had quite the experience. It was a Tuesday night, barely anyone there. We ordered a 40 dollar of wine and was brought two visibly dirty glasses. We had to scrape off whatever white bits were caked on the inside. When we asked for clean glasses she brought back two DIRTIER glasses and left the first pair on the table. Apps: tasteless, thin onion rings and "a pound and a half" (oh please!) of steamers. Once we received the food we had to ask for silverware. Meal 1: Grilled salmon. It tasted good but the whole plate was cold.. The potatoes were clearly microwaved and tasted pretty yucky. Toss on a few pieces of squash and you got yourself a 30 dollar plate lol Meal 2: Tuna burger was fine. Was given the wrong side which was a stale plate of mashed potatoes meant for someone else at the table. Meal 3: side of mashed potatoes. Pretty terrible tasting and only vaguely resembled mashed potatoes. Meal 4: Seafood Alfredo: not worth the price ($40) rubbery shrimp and the mussels weren't even touched. They looked really bad. Meal 5: steak tips, ordered medium rare came WELL done. It was all really underwhelming and the experience was hilariously bad. The view was nice though! They should train their staff and I'm sure things would turn around but it felt like everything was really sad.

Aloof Nerd

Great place on the water with a selection of fresh seafood; you can come here with family, friends, or a loved one and enjoy the scenery. The service staff is kind and accommodating in addition to the food being promptly served. I haven’t had New England sea food in a year, so it was nice to have a good experience.

Andrew Centauro

For a restaurant on the water front, we were not impressed. The calamari appetizer was not fresh. we got about 12 calamari rings, they were very rubbery. Not worth the price at all. We ordered the tuna burger, and it was pretty good. No complaints there. Unfortunately we went during low tide and being next to the beach, the sand fleas were INTOLERABLE. Most everyone on the deck was intolerant of the pests. The host staff could have mentioned it prior to seating us outside that we were going to be eaten alive. But we did get switched to an inside seat when asked, with out issue. Over all it’s a not that great, but that that bad of an establishment.

Deb Fudge

We really did stumble upon Castaways and I’m so glad we did ! We were going to a concert at Blue Ocean and wanted to find a restaurant close by. We sat at the bar and our servers were very attentive. We all ordered seafood dishes -scallops, baked haddock, lobster 🦞avocado salad. All perfectly cooked and excellent. John,one of the owners, came over to welcome us to the restaurant and was very personable. By the end of our meal, we felt like we were regulars! Can’t wait to come back, make a reservation and sit on the deck for the sunset 🌅. Kuddos to John and the whole team!