Gemelli's Pizzeria

Michael Lee

Great pizza place in the Onondaga Hill area! Prices are a bit high, but isn’t everything in 2022? Well worth the little bit extra ya have to put in. Staff are always friendly and warm. Check them out for sure!

Teletector

This was my first experience here. Ordered two New York style 18 inch pizzas, one with pepperoni and the Cajun fries. The pizza was undercooked and doughy at the crust. I paid three dollars for the pepperoni topping and they were very few pepperonis on it. I don’t think any piece had more than three pepperonis and some pieces had one and others just had two pieces of pepperoni on them. The Cajun fries were well seasoned, but soggy. but I suppose when you get french fries delivered, that’s always going to be the case. They crisped up in the air fryer All pizza restaurants seem to have high prices now. A two pizzas and french fries for $50, I expect them to be cooked properly and a fair amount of toppings for what you pay. I won’t be ordering from here again.

Erwin Webster

Worst experience ever! Manager swore on the phone to me. Wouldn’t refund my money and acknowledge that the order was messed up. All the food was cold, 2 of the 3 subs we ordered were burnt and black. It took an extra 40 mins to get here after the time they gave us. I will never order from them again.

Justin

Welcome to O-hill Gemelli's! Thanks for the deliciousness! 18" NY style, 20 buffalo wings. The pizza was excellent, spot on thin crust cooked perfectly, enjoyed every bit of it. The buffalo wings could of 100% used more sauce though, esp for buffalo wings. In the pic you can see the white spots where they aren't covered with anything, as I ate through them I didn't get any buffalo flavor, slim to none, but they were instead more on the plain side. However I was asked if I wanted them crispy, which I said yes, in that sense they were spot on and nice n crispy and good. But as far as them being buffalo, I didn't get any buffalo flavoring at all. Can't wait to try more!!!!! :)